Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
I've always driven hand me down cars but I finally decided to get a brand new car because I need something reliable for work. I have gone on test drives and done SO MUCH research but I'm curious to know which you'd pick in my situation.
I've narrowed it down to - (all 2016 models, all basic trim)
1. Mazda CX-3
2. Honda HR-V
3. Honda Fit
4. Kia Soul
5. Subaru Impreza Wagon
I'm single, commute 50 miles a day mostly in highway traffic. I set up a table at flea markets as a hobby so I need to have cargo space. I also need it to be reliable in all weather but NJ doesn't have really crazy winters.
Options aren't that important to me but safety is. I currently drive a 2003 Honda Civic and sometimes it feels like I'm driving a lawn mower but I'd rather be driving a tank!
My favorite to drive was the Mazda. It was super peppy and a great ride, but it's still too soon for the safety ratings.
The Kia dealership is offering the best deal, but when you factor in gas mileage, the Fit wins.
I would throw the base VW Golf and Kia Forte5 into that mix too. Similar cargo space as those CUVs but a much better drive with good mileage and safety as well. But I just really like hatchbacks.
I would throw the base VW Golf and Kia Forte5 into that mix too. Similar cargo space as those CUVs but a much better drive with good mileage and safety as well. But I just really like hatchbacks.
haha I don't think I can throw any more into the mix!
I've been very surprised with how well the Kia Soul compares to the others and the value. The MPG bothers me though. It's not horrible but it's not great either.
I've always driven hand me down cars but I finally decided to get a brand new car because I need something reliable for work. I have gone on test drives and done SO MUCH research but I'm curious to know which you'd pick in my situation.
I've narrowed it down to - (all 2016 models, all basic trim)
1. Mazda CX-3
2. Honda HR-V
3. Honda Fit
4. Kia Soul
5. Subaru Impreza Wagon
I'm single, commute 50 miles a day mostly in highway traffic. I set up a table at flea markets as a hobby so I need to have cargo space. I also need it to be reliable in all weather but NJ doesn't have really crazy winters.
Options aren't that important to me but safety is. I currently drive a 2003 Honda Civic and sometimes it feels like I'm driving a lawn mower but I'd rather be driving a tank!
My favorite to drive was the Mazda. It was super peppy and a great ride, but it's still too soon for the safety ratings.
The Kia dealership is offering the best deal, but when you factor in gas mileage, the Fit wins.
Any advice would be appreciated!
I love this kind of questions as I enjoy picking drives from interesting lists. I read lots of car tests each month. I am partial to Honda as both of mine have been bullet proof. However, if a good car comes along it will be noticed quickly.
I am familiar with all the cars on your list and have driven all but the first two.
I drove the Soul in a Wisconsin winter and found it had good handling, great heater but shy on the cargo space. The Fit is a great commuter car but might not hold all of your flea market finds. It would be my pick for gas mileage.
Unfortunately, the last 3 are very similar with four-wheel drive and good cargo space. The Mazda beat the HRV in a comparison test in i believe Motor Trend? The CX-3 looks sharper and is more fun to drive.
But, yes, not sure about the reliability as it is so new. Oh, and the HRV is derived from the Honda FIT platform.
My daughter has the Subaru and lives in Wisconsin and enjoys the gas mileage and the heated seats. So far it has been very reliable and good cargo space.
My order would be as follows:
Mazda CX-3
Subaru Impreza Wagon
Honda HR-V
Honda Fit
Kia Soul
They are all good cars and i suspect all are reliable and get good mileage. I personally would test drive and get the one most fun as you will be in it for hours each day. Hope this helps!
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
