Welcome to City-Data.com forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with 700,000 other registered members. User profiles and some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your free account you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 15,000 posts/day about local topics and you will see fewer ads.
My opinion sides with Schiff. There might be a deflationary cycle when the credit collapses, but the government will continue to create so much money for public works combined with foreigners selling their foreign investments and recirculating the dollars into the global money supply, I just cannot imagine a sustainable deflationary scenario.
Optimists are welcome to reply, but I'm most interested in hearing opinions from those who side with the potential for a credit meltdown.
"Global wage arbitrage is a massive deflationary force putting huge wage pressure on US jobs. Rising unemployment will do the same. Rising unemployment will affect sales as well as prices. Prices of goods and services cannot rise above peoples willingness and ability to pay higher prices. That is a simple economic fact."
But, it's not going to be painless. Time will tell.
I keep some liquid cash in my safe as a "just incase" scenario, and do not doubt a possible massive contraction of money supply in the short term. I just see it as unstable. During the GD there was massive deflation, followed by the overwhelming temptation of the government to create money to fund the New Deal causing 30+% inflation levels.
I do not doubt there will be massive deflation in non-exportable services and merchandise such as US real estate, rent, housekeeping, lawyers, accountants, architects. I just find essential services/merchandise to be inflationary in nature since these can be exported (electricity, oil, food, etc) and Mish forgets about China's ability to stop exporting goods to us. That decrease in supply of goods dilutes the value of money.
Last edited by ViewFromThePeak; 03-01-2008 at 01:42 PM..
Wages are stagnant yet food and energy are increasing substantially cutting into the incomes of especially the bottom 3 quintiles. The 4th quintile will be employed in areas where wages probably keep pace with other costs while the top 20% will probably benefit the most in the short-term from lower capital and labor costs. However, IMHO even the top 20% will be hurt in the long-run if the bottom 60% doesn't have some disposible income to spend on nondiscretionary items.
Wages are stagnant yet food and energy are increasing substantially cutting into the incomes of especially the bottom 3 quintiles. The 4th quintile will be employed in areas where wages probably keep pace with other costs while the top 20% will probably benefit the most in the short-term from lower capital and labor costs. However, IMHO even the top 20% will be hurt in the long-run if the bottom 60% doesn't have some disposible income to spend on nondiscretionary items.
Crime is already on the increase. Showing the pressures on the 60%. It will be a back breaker to local and state economies. In Oregon the cost of incarceration alone is 10.9% of the State budget.
Crime is already on the increase. Showing the pressures on the 60%. It will be a back breaker to local and state economies. In Oregon the cost of incarceration alone is 10.9% of the State budget.
freedom
This is why I believe inflation or God forbid hyperinflation will take hold. These public works projects to keep the population under control by increased size of prisons will cost a lot of money from the federal budget. You could reduce the cost by building large internment centers or concentration camps, but of course that is extremely controvesial and feeds further dissention among the population.
We need a national inititative. Alternative energy development and independence could be the catalyst for our country to start be a major producer again. Urban redevelopment centered around modern transportation that is not auto-oriented could provide many domestic employment opportunities.
Time to tell the Middle East, Venezula, and others that we are not going to be your "oil junkies."
My opinion sides with Schiff. There might be a deflationary cycle when the credit collapses, but the government will continue to create so much money for public works combined with foreigners selling their foreign investments and recirculating the dollars into the global money supply, I just cannot imagine a sustainable deflationary scenario.
Optimists are welcome to reply, but I'm most interested in hearing opinions from those who side with the potential for a credit meltdown.
So who is considered more optimistic the inflationist or deflationist? My old friend Mish has become a marketing machine with his deflationary thesis taken to extremes even with everything we need (outside of housing) going up in price dramatically in the past two years in the face of the greatest housing/credit meltdown since the great depression. Really, stagflation and a return of the misery index of the 1970's is the great fear. We will easily get out of the current mess if broad money supply globally continues growing at a 15% clip and US is allowed to still borrow long term at only 5% but some pain and a decline in living standards for many American's unprepared for the future. GWB's very low approval rating and collapsing dollar signal the squeeze going on the average American from all sides that is currently worse than a deflationist's wet dream of eternal doom and gloom. But this will soon pass to IMHO and Mish and others like him will be looked at as the carbon copies of Ravi Batra and his wonderful book "The Depression of 1990" rehashing the same premise again and again. We had our deflation moments in recent times around 1991 and again in 2001 IMHO..
I'm wondering if people are being influenced with their emotional tie to paper money as an indicator. I'm rather surprised at the # of responses to the deflation scenario.
I can also see an oscillating situation. Deflation followed by hyperinflation and the like. Money supply contracts instantly from "lost money" in credit and the government pumping tons of money to Americans who weren't prudent enough to be liquid and are literally starving in the streets.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Welcome to City-Data.com forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with 700,000 other registered members. User profiles and some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your free account you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 15,000 posts/day about local topics and you will see fewer ads. 
Please, doom&gloomers only: Post-credit collapse, inflation or deflation?
Linear Mode
