Wellness also makes a great canned food! Smells like chicken soup. As long as your kitty doesn't have any special dietary needs (like a prescription diet) I would try a bunch of different foods and see what she likes. We have had clients who feed their cats baby food, and I have never heard one of our vets curse them out for it
but just for mixing in for flavor, not for their actual main diet.
Some good brands of natural like foods in addition to the Wellness, Innova, Newmans own....we have a dog food called california natural, and I assume that they also make cat food. I recommend these for a couple of reasons...one, they are all natural type foods and high quality diets, but also they all have similar types of ingredients so you could switch between them with less likely stomach upset.
Good luck