Pennsylvania Versus Florida: Which State Do You Prefer? (better, crime rate, population)

[PITTSTON2SARASOTA]

I grew up in Pennsylvania but moved to Florida 20 years ago. I must say I prefer Pennsylvania mainly because it has more "diversity" geographically and the economy is not so dependant on continual large population increases(which is unsustainable). The accelerated population growth has led to a high crime rate and a loss of identity for the state. Overall I feel that the quality of life in Florida suffers because it has too many transplanted residents....including me....LOL....

[Drover]

To answer the question in the title of the thread: PA by a long shot.

[SteelCityRising]

I actually miss quite a bit about Pennsylvania. Even though many people there weren't quite the most cultured, tolerant, or progressive people that side of the Mason-Dixon Line I would still rather be with a group of them at a social gathering than a group of people from NoVA flatulating about classical music, a debate on Mercedes vs. Lexus, grey poupon vs. caviar, yada, yada, yada. There's something to be said about being down-to-earth. I appreciate that people in NoVA can also talk intelligently about politics, foreign affairs, the economy, etc., etc. and are generally more respectful of diifferent cultures/ideals/races (i.e. not as much gay-bashing here), but there is a definite aura of "prestige" here where you feel left out if you make sub-$50,000/year, as I do.

I know you were asking about Florida, but I know since we are both derived from the same small hometown in PA you probably know where I'm coming from with missing the small town festivals, the old homes, the mom-and-pop restaurants, the beautiful churches (although most in Pittston, PA are now abandoned), etc.

[History Rules]

But Florida has more of the other kinds of diversity!!!

[History Rules]

But all things considered Pennsylvania by a huge landslide. Used to live in Philly, love the history of Independence Hall, Valley Forge, 4 seasons, 2 hours from NY, Pittsburgh is also a great city. Not a fan of heat or humidity.

[PITTSTON2SARASOTA]

Originally Posted by ScranBarre

I actually miss quite a bit about Pennsylvania. Even though many people there weren't quite the most cultured, tolerant, or progressive people that side of the Mason-Dixon Line I would still rather be with a group of them at a social gathering than a group of people from NoVA flatulating about classical music, a debate on Mercedes vs. Lexus, grey poupon vs. caviar, yada, yada, yada. There's something to be said about being down-to-earth. I appreciate that people in NoVA can also talk intelligently about politics, foreign affairs, the economy, etc., etc. and are generally more respectful of diifferent cultures/ideals/races (i.e. not as much gay-bashing here), but there is a definite aura of "prestige" here where you feel left out if you make sub-$50,000/year, as I do.

I know you were asking about Florida, but I know since we are both derived from the same small hometown in PA you probably know where I'm coming from with missing the small town festivals, the old homes, the mom-and-pop restaurants, the beautiful churches (although most in Pittston, PA are now abandoned), etc.

You hit the nail on the head....we miss the relative "friendliness" of the people and as you stated the more earthy mentality. Here it is mainly wealthy and sometimes snobish people....everyone else seems to be "left out of the equation". Part of the real estate bubble was caused by greedy people flipping properties and now we are all paying for it. Sarasota calls itself cultured but I have seen better plays and nicer venues in Scranton or Wilkes-Barre....it is all about image. Also....as you also alluded...Florida does not have a "history" like Pennsylvania...it seems to lack "soul". And the architecture of the older Pennsylvania cities, including churches is far more diverse than here. It comes down to that "help your neighbor/watch out for your neighbor" mindset, which I personally have never experienced in Florida.

[PITTSTON2SARASOTA]

Originally Posted by History Rules

But all things considered Pennsylvania by a huge landslide. Used to live in Philly, love the history of Independence Hall, Valley Forge, 4 seasons, 2 hours from NY, Pittsburgh is also a great city. Not a fan of heat or humidity.

I totally agree.... I used to love traveling in Pennsylvania...with the mountains and valleys....you never got bored with the terrain or diversity of flora and fauna.

[tallydude02]

I lived in Florida several years ago. Although wasn't a horrible experience (some on this board paint as the portal to Hell), I prefer Pennsylvania. I just recently moved to the southwestern part of the state, but where I was before (Clarksburg, WV which is about 80 miles away) isn't that radically different. I like it so far. I moved to PA for a better job (yes, good jobs exist in southwestern PA, they are hard to find though).

I like PA's mountains and overall scenery though. FL is a bit too flat for my tastes. Also PA is alot closer to home and more familiar.

[DailyJournalist]

Originally Posted by History Rules

But all things considered Pennsylvania by a huge landslide. Used to live in Philly, love the history of Independence Hall, Valley Forge, 4 seasons, 2 hours from NY, Pittsburgh is also a great city. Not a fan of heat or humidity.

I agree, Pennsylvania is far superior! Especially in the job market and wages.

[PITTSTON2SARASOTA]

Originally Posted by tallydude02

I lived in Florida several years ago. Although wasn't a horrible experience (some on this board paint as the portal to Hell), I prefer Pennsylvania. I just recently moved to the southwestern part of the state, but where I was before (Clarksburg, WV which is about 80 miles away) isn't that radically different. I like it so far. I moved to PA for a better job (yes, good jobs exist in southwestern PA, they are hard to find though).

I like PA's mountains and overall scenery though. FL is a bit too flat for my tastes. Also PA is alot closer to home and more familiar.

Florida is not as bad as some of us say.....but close....LOL.... the flat terrain is so monotonous.....interstate travel is not the natural wonder that it is in Pennsylvania.