Hi, AdamandKim -
So, if I'm reading your posts correctly, you're looking for an affordable area near Dayton with historic homes and excellent elementary schools? Correct?
Well, at the risk of sounding like a broken record on this forum, I'll chime in again with Tipp City and Troy.
I live in Tipp and frequently visit Troy. The neighboring towns both have the advantage of being ideally located on I-75, but surrounded by corn fields as well
TAXES/HOMES/SITUATION
Because both are in Miami County, they'll have lower taxes than popular Montgomery County areas like Centerville, Kettering, Huber Heights, and Vandalia. Also, they both have lovely historic districts with the kind of Victorian homes you mentioned. And, both towns are very walkable.
HISTORIC DISTRICTS
Troy has a small first-run movie theater, several great restaurants (La Piazza is especially good for an Italian bistro feel), Hayner Culture Center, the public library, an Irish pub, an awesome throwback-style diner, an indoor ice rink, and a neat coffee/sandwich/ice cream shop called Night Sky.
Tipp misses out on the movie theater, but the downtown historic district has wonderful restaurants (Coldwater Cafe and Harrison's are great), a cozy coffeehouse with awesome desserts, a deli, a fun breakfast spot (Sam & Ethel's), lots of artsy/antique stores, the public library, barbershops, bars, a family-owned ice cream shop, pizza, two parks, an aquatic center, the high school's football/soccer stadium, and a corner grocery for last-minute items. On most Fridays during the summer, you'll find live music out on the sidewalk outside the Hotel Gallery, and several shops stay open late to accommodate the restaurant crowd. Great atmosphere!
SCHOOLS
Regarding schools, both districts are good. I'm not as familiar with Troy's system, but it is Division I in sports (the largest division in the area) and gets good academic ratings. Tipp is often praised throughout the state for its schools -- and especially the level of community pride/support that follows them. We have a brand new high school, VERY competitive sports, and some interesting academic options (like studying Mandarin Chinese at the high school level).
Note: if you're doing your homework on the Ohio Department of Education site, it should be noted that the school names are a little tricky.
Zip 45373 = Troy = Troy City Schools = Troy High School
Zip 45371 = Tipp = Tipp City Schools = Tippecanoe High School
and also
Zip 45371 = Bethel Township = Bethel Local Schools = Bethel High School
Tipp City proper goes to Tippecanoe. The neighboring rural area to the east goes to Bethel in an entirely separate school district. Just FYI!
SHOPPING & DINING OUTSIDE THE HISTORIC DISTRICTS
Okay, finally . . . convenience. Tipp is more centrally located, but both towns offer easy access via I-75 or I-70 to the Dayton International Airport (5 minute drive), Ginghamsburg Church (a popular megachurch), downtown Dayton (15-20 minutes on the interstate), etc.
Tipp itself offers the historic district plus an area near the interstate with Chin's China Grill (very popular, upscale); Hickory River Barbeque; a full-service grocery store; Subway, Taco Bell, Burger King, McDonald's, Wendy's, Arby's, Frisch's (sp?), Bob Evans, etc.; banks; and a Holiday Inn Express.
Troy, just 3 or 4 miles north on I-75, offers all of the above plus Lowe's, Meijer, Super Wal-Mart, Staples, Outback, Applebee's, more hotels, Kroger, Blockbuster, etc.
If you go a little south from both communities along SR 202, you hit the northern part of Huber Heights which offers Elder Beerman (department store), Kohl's, Marshall's, Target, another Lowe's, another Staples, another Meijer, another Super Wal-Mart, Ruby Tuesday's, Hobby Lobby, Bed Bath & Beyond, etc. and Showcase Cinemas complex.
And, if you go south just an exit or two on I-75, you hit what we lovingly call "Restaurant Row." It's at the Benchwood exit in Vandalia, and they have many hotels along with literally every chain casual-dining restaurant ever made: Panera, Red Lobster, Joe's Crabshack, Outback, Don Pablo's, Tim Horton's, Olive Garden, etc.
And if, heaven forbid, that's not enough for shopping and dining options, you can shoot down I-675 to Fairfield Commons or the Greene in Beavercreek. Between those two mall areas, you'll find Macy's, Sears, Penney's, another Elder Beerman, Best Buy, TJ Maxx, Michael's, another Target, all the usual mall stores like Abercrombie and Banana Republic, and another long list of restaurants like Fleming's, Cheesecake Factory, Adobe Gilas, McCormick & Schmick's (coming soon), Potbelly, Brio Tuscan Grille, BD's Mongolian Grille, another Panera, Bar Louie, Cafe Istanbul, Mimi's, etc.
Seriously, it's a wonder we're not all maxed out on our credit cards and weighing 500 pounds with all these options!
SUMMARY
Well, if you eat too much, come back to your adorable Victorian in Tipp's historic district and walk it all off by heading up to the city park and then window shopping on your way back through Main Street. And, forget waiting for the school bus. Your kids can walk safely to Broadway Elementary. Swing by the farm market on Saturday morning. And, head out to Fulton Farms for fresh produce every day, all summer. Does life really get any better than this?
