How about Eaton? It is an older community with good schools and older homes. It is about an hour drive into Dayton. It seems that Preble County doesn't get mentioned to often. Maybe I've been here so long that there is something everyone knows about Preble that I don't.
When my son started school we moved to Preble County. We were living in Dayton at the time. I hated the Dayton Public School system. The funny thing is, I graduated from a Dayton high school. One would not believe what has happened to these schools in 30 years time. Sad for the people that can't leave and find better options for their children. Shouldn't have to.
Germantown is another option. It has been a great town as long as I remember. My grandparents lived there most of my life and I don't think it has ever changed. The school system is a great one. It has lovely older homes and new construction as well.