Quote:
Originally Posted by wutitiz
If you bother to read the link, the exercises are actually from a Univ of Calgary prof of kinesiology. Anyway joint soreness w/o muscle soreness is to me an indicator that something is off track. Maybe the soreness "goes away," or maybe he ends up as another statistic who ends up having to go under the knife.
|
I did read the link and the study, I may have miscommunicated the fact that it isn't relevant to the OP.
[edit] Long story short - he isn't a runner and applying a runner's remedy to a person that is strength training makes no sense.
Anyways.
Here is the study:
Suspected Mechanisms in the Cause of Overuse Running Injuries
Quote:
Suspected Mechanisms in the Cause of Overuse Running Injuries
ContextThe question then becomes, are there common mechanisms related to overuse running injuries?
Conclusion
In contrast, a large and growing body of literature suggests that weakness of hip-stabilizing muscles leads to atypical lower extremity mechanics and increased forces within the lower extremity while running.
|
The article states that runner's suffer from overuse injuries, which must be supplemented by strength training. The OP writes that he is primarily weight lifting and jumping rope, not running. The target is not an overuse-running issue, therefore the remedy should not be something that fixes an overuse-running issue.
The target is an overuse-weightlifting issue. Consider Pauala Radcliffe, British Marathon runner that used squats and deadlifts to rehabilitate (
Strength Training for Distance Running | Muscle Finesse). Strength training is commonly understood to build strength, increase bone density and soft tissue density (
Effects of resistance training on regional ... [J Bone Miner Res. 1995] - PubMed - NCBI). Running does not increase strength, bone or soft tissue density.
If we suggest the runners world hip exercises to 'fix' his issue (a) we are suggesting the problem is too much running; (b) we are taking a step backwards and in the wrong direction. The remedy for overuse in weightlifting is primarily rest for beginners or deloading for intermediate to advanced individuals.
Joint pain without muscle soreness doesn't always mean something is 'off-track'. If we are to consider Reed Ferber's article, anywhere between 30-70% of recreational to competitive runner's experience some sort of overuse injury in a one year period. Approximately 50% of injuries to runners occur at the knee; patellofemoral pain syndrome is the most common, followed by iliotibial band syndrome, meniscal injuries and pateller tendinitis. Foot, ankle and lower leg injuries account for 40%. These overuse injuries (to the joint) are those common to most people; as such they train through these overuse injuries as the rehabilitate. Treatment of patellar tendinitis usually involves stretching and strengthening of muscles around the knee.
So, the remedy? Rest. Most people can't start squatting and pulling 3x a week and be okay with it. I however, trained a female to squat and pull 2x a week for five weeks before squatting and pulling 3-4 times (at 65-90% 1rm) a week with no soreness (joint or muscle).