Well, state your goals!

What was your athletic field? It's awesome that you enjoy weight training.
I'm a fan of Upper/Lower split done 2x/week. Example:
Upper Body (vertical/horizontal push/pull):
Bent Over Rows or T-Bar Row 5(sets)x5(reps) (low horizontal pull)
Dips (weighted if necessary) 5x5 (horizontal push)
Pullups 3x8 (vertical pull)
Low Incline Bench Press or Flat Bench Press 3x8 (horizontal push)
Standing DB Press 3x12 (vertical push)
Face Pulls 3x12 (high horizontal pull)
Lower (push/pull):
Squats 5x5 (push)
Dead Lifts 5x5 (pull)
Lunges 3x8 (push)
Good Mornings or Hyperextensions 3x8 (pull)
Calf Raises 3x8 (push)
You can vary exercises up depending on what you're trying to achieve. What's lagging for you? Back? Legs? Shoulders? Chest?