[Jannie]

Inquiring about different kinds of Auto insurance in Naples. No advertising please, I just would like to know which is a decent agency. I do not want to combine my auto insurance with homeowners insurance at the same place. I like to keep everthing separate. I have an older car and would like to know which agencies are at least decent and which will rob you blind.

[SoFLGal]

I would choose Geico as well. I just switched to them after being with Allstate for 15 years. Bottom line is better service and better rates.

[debidibly]

I personally found Geico to be several hundred dollars a year more for identical coverage. I have Mercury Insurance which I understand can be a little tough to get but much less money.

[doggiebus]

I just got a cheaper rate with State Farm so went with them. I just left Liberty mutual because they were ripping me off big time, save over 1k switching to State Farm (for the same policy). Don't go with Progressive. I have heard they have their own body shop that they prefer you use. And if you do decide to go with your own body shop many shops will not even consider working on your car if you have Progressive. My parents were in an accident a few months ago and the person asked if the person that hit my parents had Progressive, they said no. The guy at the shop said good, because we will not do any work for some insured with Progressive. Something with getting payed by Progressive and problems.