Favorite Ice Cream (rum, coffee, peanut butter, homemade)

[Regina14]

Originally Posted by cbr11

Ben & Jerry's used to have a flavor called Wavy Gravy. It was some of the best ice cream I ever had. Which, of course, meant it had to be discontinued.


Baskin Robbins Peanut Butter & Chocolate is my absolute fave, but I do not live near one anymore, so it's a special treat when I visit family back home. their Rocky Road is also great.


Graeter's Mint Chocolate Chip is pretty good, in a pinch.

Baskin-Robbins Peanut Butter & Chocolate is probably my all-time favorite too; but there are not any Baskin-Robbins nearby anymore. I also used to love chocolate/fudge ribbon flavors; but they don't seem to make them (chocolate or fudge winding through vanilla) as much anymore, anywhere.

[Dirt Grinder]

Originally Posted by 1Potato2Potato3Potato4

This made me think of Mister Softie and the Good Humor man that used to drive around the neighborhood in the summer when I was a kid...

In London we used to get a 99 Flake. It's a vanilla soft-serve ice cream with a Flake chocolate bar stuck in it.

[Ottawa2011]

I prefer gelato...more intense flavour... vanilla, or raspberry. If I do get brand ice cream, then it's Haagen Daz Vanilla Bean.

[JayInCA]

Originally Posted by toosie

The only grocery store brand I buy is Haagen Dazs. I prefer their plain ones like chocolate, coffee, strawberry, pistachio - not rum raisin, rocky road ones.

I agree, I love Haagen Dazs! Try the green tea ice cream if you haven't already, it's so good.

[toosie]

Originally Posted by 1Potato2Potato3Potato4

Chocolate Eclair bars from Good Humor..

Used to love those - could go for one now!

Originally Posted by Dirt Grinder

In London we used to get a 99 Flake. It's a vanilla soft-serve ice cream with a Flake chocolate bar stuck in it.

Pathetic as it may sound - this was already on my list of things to eat while in London this August

Originally Posted by JayInCA

I agree, I love Haagen Dazs! Try the green tea ice cream if you haven't already, it's so good.

Haven't, but I will - thanks for the recommendation - I already know I like 90% or more of the food you like!

[DubbleT]

Bluebell, Italian cream cake, followed by their spiced pumpkin pecan. It's probably a good thing they aren't available year round!

[Dirt Grinder]

Originally Posted by toosie

...this was already on my list of things to eat while in London this August...

I've made them over here, but they just don't taste the same - and the unique cone shape is part of the fun.

[Delahanty]

We don't often have ice cream at home. But DH is a huge fan of milkshakes and, when he has a hankering, I get Perry's chocolate, and make both of us a shake.

We do like cones in the summer, though.

[ylisa7]

Originally Posted by cbr11

Ben & Jerry's used to have a flavor called Wavy Gravy. It was some of the best ice cream I ever had. Which, of course, meant it had to be discontinued.


Baskin Robbins Peanut Butter & Chocolate is my absolute fave, but I do not live near one anymore, so it's a special treat when I visit family back home. their Rocky Road is also great.


Graeter's Mint Chocolate Chip is pretty good, in a pinch.

They sell Baskin Robbin in grocery stores now I just found that out as I am still a sucker for their chocolate chip.

[Star10101]

Originally Posted by ZolaLloyd

Carte D'Or, "Rum & Raisin" ice cream, is like heaven on a spoon!

Oh look who's on here, talking about ice cream!

This is a tough decision. It would have to be between a Magnum Mini Double Caramel, a Peanut Butter Cornetto and some Ben & Jerry's Caramel Chew Chew.