Pumpkin Pie vs. Sweet Potato Pie (turkey, dinner, cheese, serving)

[Caligula1]

I went with pumpkin but I like them both very much, being from NY I never even knew they made such delicious things such as sweet potato pie and pecan pie..

[temptation001]

Of the two, I much rather the pumpkin pie, its so creamy and smooth and tastes so good coming out of the fridge. I also like sweet potatoes on the side, but not the pie. Other pies I like are cheesecake, pecan pie (YUM!), and that's pretty much it for my favorites.

[LinaJo76]

Well, I never was much of a pie person (I'm a cake lover). But I do love the classic Pumpkin Pie, of course.

[AmazinGracie]

I love pumpkin pie and for the life of me, I don't know why I only eat at for TDay! I am, however, very partial to MY pumpkin pie. No frozen or bakery pie can compare. It is just the Libby's recipe with a little extra of all the spices (think rounded vs level measuring spoon). And it must be cold and naked (no whipped cream for me!)

[cocomojo]

I like pumpkin okay, but I LOVE sweet potato. We make them dark in my family (lots of nutmet and cinnamon).

[TKramar]

no preference.

For me, they're pretty much interchangeable and taste alike.

[graytabbie]

I'll take pumpkin over sweet potato, but I love, love, love pie, any pie (even mincemeat and raisin) I used to request birthday pie instead of birthday cake.

[TabulaRasa]

Both are absolutely wondrous. I'd be hard pressed to choose. I'd like a slice of each, please. And good, strong coffee.

[southernnaturelover]

Originally Posted by TKramar

no preference.

For me, they're pretty much interchangeable and taste alike.

Same here.

[Ohiogirl81]

Sweet potato pie gives me heartburn, dunno why, since both pies have pretty much the same ingredients.

I also prefer the texture of pumpkin pie to sweet potato pie.