Jason Campbell (WAS) vs. Matt Schaub (HOU) (preseason, league, game)

[jfkIII]

12-team Fantasy Football League.

We each pick 2 QBs (and play them each week). I was the last to pick my 2nd QB, so there was not much left.. it came down to Jason Campbell or Matt Schaub (Trent Green & Rex Grossman are also still available as free agents, if I wanted to change).

Who would you pick out of the group above?

Thanks.

[X-Greensboro Resident]

I'd go with Matt Schaub because I think Campbell got hurt in a preseason game and is not 100%. Also, Washington is more of a running team where Houston will put it up in the air more.

[jfkIII]

Thanks, X. I just proposed a trade with another owner...Jason Campbell & Marion Barber for Eli Manning & Jerious Norwood. I'm overstocked with RBs (L.Maroney, W.Parker, M.Barber & T.Bell). He's only got R.Brown, D.Williams, J.Norwood & P.Holmes. My other QB is Kitna. His other QB is P.Manning.

[X-Greensboro Resident]

OOOHH, Would he trade Peyton Manning? That would be a good QB on your team. Kitna is also a good pick because they'll throw the ball a lot in Detroit and they have good receivers, the only problem with Kitna is INTs, he had a lot of them last year. Good luck!

[nl2134]

Well, let's see...

The Dolphins have Chris Chambers and Ronnie Brown
The Redskins have Santana Moss and Clinton Portis
The Texans have Andre Johnson and Ahman Green

That is tough. I'll probably go with Schaub. He's on the worst of the teams (maybe the Dolphins could be worse), less talented running back (not to take away from Ahman Green but Portis and Brown are both solid), and more of a deep threat in Johnson. Chambers is solid as a deep threat also, but may have his DUI lingering over him...