I'm not sure what type of meter that you used, but there are quite a few that have some issues with them. Having tried my fair share of meters over the years, I have found that many of the cheap ones, although having an attractive price, did not behave in a desirable manner. What has happened to many of the sensors I've tried are one of 2 things. Either the sensor itself corroded, giving inaccurate readings, or salinity in the soil (i.e. fertilizer) gives a false reading, saying the soil is more moist than it really is. Moving from sensor to sensor, I finally broke down and got this
Soil Moisture Meter. Though it is a little more expensive than the cheap ones you'll find at home depot, the results have been well worth the money. I have been using it for 3 years now, and I haven't run into any issues. It runs just as accurately as one would expect.
If you don't want to buy another sensor (Believe me, I've been there...) you have a few other options. If corrosion is the issue on your meter, I've heard you can clean it off with a piece of steel wool. Not really sure what to do about the salinity issue... The other option is the time old, do it yourself. You can either stick your finger or a piece of bamboo into the soil, and if it comes up dry, it is time for another watering. The other option is to either kick or lift the pot to get the sense of the weight. If it is to easy to move, add more water.
Anyways, that's my 2 cents. Hope this helps!