Is There A future for Jews Outside Israel, the U.S., Canada & Australia? (Congress, Israeli)
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
Better questions are: Will Israel ever stop murdering Palestinians?
And
Why is Israel's genocidal aggression toward the Palestinian people not condemned by the United States and all decent human beings in every country?
And,
Why does the US continue to lick Israel's buttocks?
The topic and Great Debate question is about the future of the Jews outside the English speaking world and Israel. If you don't believe that the Jews should have a future that is a topic for debate but not on this thread.
But the fact that your post may seem out of the mainstream demonstrates that we in the U.S. support Jews and Israel, by and large. But as you illustrate that support is not unanimous.
The Great Debate question is whether the Jewish people can safely exist and build a life and a community anywhere besides Israel, the U.S., Canada & Australia?
I believe the answer is a firm "no."
You left out all of Latin America.
My neighborhood I live in here in Mexico City is heavily Jewish. They get along fine with the other Mexicans, and vice versa.
I go to my nearest Costco only on Saturdays (Shabat), because it is empty, lol......
Last edited by snebarekim; 03-30-2018 at 11:33 AM..
Sure they can. England, Wales, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, Japan, etc. just to name a few. It's a big planet. Some may be better choices than others, but it's do-able.
England is not great for Jews, although it hasn't seen the physical attacks and murders that France has. The de rigueur PC position is that Jews, not just Israel, are on the wrong side of the fence regarding Palestine and that's that. Go to any UK college or university if you want to see that. England is a pretty PC-beholden country, and its still best keeping your head down if Jewish.
Wales, not so PC-imprisoned, even though its part of the UK.
Better questions are: Will Israel ever stop murdering Palestinians?
And
Why is Israel's genocidal aggression toward the Palestinian people not condemned by the United States and all decent human beings in every country?
And,
Why does the US continue to lick Israel's buttocks?
And even better question is does the world need yet another islamist country?
That'll be good for humanity. That's just what it needs. I mean its working out great for human rights in all the rest of them so far.
America also might be trending anti-Jewish. At the last Democratic convention most delegates voice-voted against Israel's right to exist, which was covered up only by the machinations of the Party chair. The Party's old Eastern European flavor socialism is being replaced by a newer 3rd world oriented one.
Historically Jews have been targeted by the Right. This is well known and true. Jews were accused of being left-wing oriented, which was also true and was one of the reasons the Right resented them.
Now, the ire against Jews is sourced more from the Left. The Left's anti-nationstate traits have come out, including against Israel. More, the Left supports the Palestinians as one of the oppressed peoples it likes.
With the Left's reorientation along an anti-Semitic axis, regimes that once tolerated Jews might be replaced by ones that don't.
There are also Rightist groups, especially in Europe, that are resurgent and might tumble into their bad old ways.
Hulsker... Do you know you didn't refute anything that was posted?
I have no idea if there is more anti-semitism on the political left or right, but showing examples of anti-semitism on the right does nothing to disprove the statement that most anti-semitism comes from the left.
Hulsker... Do you know you didn't refute anything that was posted?
I have no idea if there is more anti-semitism on the political left or right, but showing examples of anti-semitism on the right does nothing to disprove the statement that most anti-semitism comes from the left.
Really? and where's your proof that the anti-semitism on the left is worse than the right? Or is this another blame the left for every bad thing that happens comment with no substance?
Alberto Nisman was appointed special prosecutor by Kirchner’s husband, then president Nestor Kirchner, and he quickly showed his investigation would be far-reaching.
On his request, British authorities in 2003 arrested Iran’s former ambassador to Buenos Aires, Hadi Soleimanpour, but he was released on bail for lack of evidence.
In 2015, Nisman’s body was found in his Buenos Aires apartment with a gunshot wound to the head, delivered at close range from a handgun found at his side.
I wouldn't exactly call Cristina Kirshner's complicity in the cover-up of the bombing a reassuring omen in Latin America for a Jewish future. Or, for that matter, their earlier sanctuary for Adolph Eichmann and numerous other Nazis.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
