Great School Analysis

[BKOTH97]

Originally Posted by flowslikeabutterfly

No, We are paying for Randolph for K-9 and then switching to Bob Jones. We took a detailed tour of the public school here in Madison (I am slated for one of the nicest ones) and it's still lacking. There are virtually no arts/music until middle school and Randolph way outpaces the academic side (its a 2 time national blue ribbon winner). I'm sorry, but status quo is not good enough for my child. I was a public school child and hold a PHD, but the struggle was ridiculous growing up. I need to give my child the best. Any yes, Randolph has a tough admission policy and requires testing for entrance. Its not for every kid.

No need for the elitist attitude. I am also a public school child. I have a Master's degree in Computer Science and I didn't struggle growing up. My family goes to Madison City Schools and uses a private music program. My 6 year old plays piano with both hands, transposes and composes music and can sing while playing. My 3 year old also plays with one hand and simultaneously sings. She is also doing some basic composition.

The Madison public schools are fine, you can augment with private programs that suit your specific art/music needs and desires without the exorbitant cost of Randolph. My 2c.

[flstatenolefan]

My...the educational snobbery is just oozing out of this thread

[Southlander]

I don't mind that someone chooses private school, public school, or homeschooling. I do mind when someone talks about how awful my choice is, and how they'd NEVER send their child there. I've gotten that from parochial, private, and home schoolers, as well as parents of children assigned to certain "choice" public schools.
Guess it's a human nature thing. That's why it's good to THINK before you post.

[BKOTH97]

Originally Posted by flstatenolefan

My...the educational snobbery is just oozing out of this thread

I apologize if I came across like that, but I was simply trying to make the point that Public schools in Madison (and some areas of Huntsville) are fine and there is no reason to go to Randolph. There are a pleathora of private art/music programs in the area that can compensate if that is the area of concern.

[mm42]

Originally Posted by BKOTH97

there is no reason to go to Randolph.

I have to say, that's a rather idiotic blanket statement.

[BKOTH97]

Originally Posted by mm42

I have to say, that's a rather idiotic blanket statement.

Given the point of the argument, I disagree. The crux of the argument was that Madison Art/Music programs were lacking thus the need to go to Randolph to gain access to a quality program. I do not believe that is the case. There are many quality private art/music programs that rival or exceed what Randolph offers (at a much lower cost).

It wasn't a blanket statement at all. It was focused on the specific argument.

[mm42]

Originally Posted by BKOTH97

Given the point of the argument, I disagree. The crux of the argument was that Madison Art/Music programs were lacking thus the need to go to Randolph to gain access to a quality program. I do not believe that is the case. There are many quality private art/music programs that rival or exceed what Randolph offers (at a much lower cost).

Well, you've explained your rationale more than once, but it does not support the conclusion "there is no reason to go to Randolph".

You are obviously happy with your education choice, but it is ridiculous to state that anyone who makes a different choice is operating outside of reason.

[flstatenolefan]

Originally Posted by BKOTH97

I apologize if I came across like that, but I was simply trying to make the point that Public schools in Madison (and some areas of Huntsville) are fine and there is no reason to go to Randolph. There are a pleathora of private art/music programs in the area that can compensate if that is the area of concern.

Actually, you were not the one I was referring to when I made that comment...LOL. I apologize for the confusion. I completely understand the points you are making and agree.

[BKOTH97]

Originally Posted by mm42

Well, you've explained your rationale more than once, but it does not support the conclusion "there is no reason to go to Randolph".

You are obviously happy with your education choice, but it is ridiculous to state that anyone who makes a different choice is operating outside of reason.

I am perfectly happy to agree to disagree on the matter.