Here I am!
I feel much the same as Apanda does about the 32246 area....great area overall, the lousy high school - Sandalwood - is a shortcoming though. Elementary and Middle are no problem, as you already realized.
There are definitely some older neighborhoods, but there are a lot of new neighborhoods too (built in the last 5 years or so). Once you expand to include 32225, you have a
ton of newer neighborhoods to consider. Many of them are not visible from the main road, so it's good you have a realtor to show you around

.
You'll be far closer to the beach than your desired 25 minutes, you'll be more like 10-15 minutes at the most. You'll be the same or less to the Saint Johns Town Center as well. Access to I295/9A is great from these zips, especially from 32246.
There's a great brand new park in 32246 too - Huffman Park on Huffman Road. It's a beautiful 15 acre park with on-site security and everything, be sure to take your daughter there to check it out

.
You have oodles of neighborhoods to choose from, and I definitely don't know all of them, but here are a few that come to mind for 32246 & 32225 that I would recommend looking at, in no particular order:
Sutton Lakes
Coachman Meadows
Coachman Lakes
Canterwood
Hawkins Cove
The Woods
Windsor Chase
Kensington
If you see a neighborhood you're considering, feel free to DM me

.