* Al Hodge (as Captain Video (1955 - 1956)
* Jon Gnagy (mid late 1950's)
* Sandy Becker (1955-56, and again from 1957-59)
* Pat Meikle (co-hosting from 1955 to 1956)
*
Herb Sheldon (1956-1957)
* Bill Britten (best known as New York's Bozo the Clown, co-host in 1958)
* Doris Faye (co-host in 1958)
* Sonny Fox (1959-1967)
* Bob McAllister (1967-1977)
Each week, audience members of Wonderama received a goodie bag as detailed on the show, containing varying items including:
* An Oral-B toothbrush
* An issue of Dynamite Magazine
* A supply of Good Humor ice cream
* A box of Hostess Twinkies
* A 6-pack of RC Cola
* A package of Fruit Stripe Gum
* A gift certificate for Burger King or McDonald's
* A pack of Lender's Bagelettes.
(Each child also got a necklace made from a Lenders Bagelette which had either their name or their last initial painted on it.)
* And a 45 record of one of the music artists who performed on the Wonderama episode each week.
Today they'd get a slice of wheat break, soy milk and a copy of Earth in the Balance.