I'm from Northern NJ originally. I spent 22 1/2 years in the area you are thinking of moving to, please consider the following. Garrett county has 3 seasons Winter, mud season and August. The county has more "gray" days than sunshine. It has a summer population that clogs the roads, grocery stores, so on and so forth. If you want to shop you have to get on the interstate and go to Morgantown, WV, or Cumberland, Md.
Deep Creek lake has been overbuilt and overpriced. Be careful if you are considering living around the lake area, esp. with well and septic.
Be careful with the locals because it is part of the Bible belt and everybody is somebody's cousin. (no kidding) Social life, good in the summer, winter you will hibernate and best to buy an AWD car or SUV.
Great fun riding a motorcycle in the area. We still have friends we go back and see. But we now live on the eastern shore of Maryland and looking to move closer to the beach. Good local people, yes, close knit and clannish, yes. There is a population of "transplants" to make friends with, start at Brenda's Pizza and tell them Richie sent ya! Good Luck
