hi -
I just got home from a househunting trip up there. My husband will be working in the financial district, so is also going to S. Station.
We are all about Hingham, but I don't see how we can afford it. I think the people who are saying the commute is a nightmare haven't considered the new train (something like 35 minutes to S. Station) and the ferry, which is I think 30 minutes.
They have excellent schools, lots for families/kids, and the library is,compared to every other town we looked in, incredible. I put the libraries on my tour b/c you can tell a lot about the town, their funding, their priorities for their funding, education, etc. etc. by how the library is. Collection, age of collection, programming, etc. etc. etc.
The only other library that came even close was Duxbury... but it too is a hike.(and expensive) We LOVE the water (being sailors) and the train from Kingston is comparable (I think 6 minutes longer) than it is from, oh, I'm drawing a blank here, I think it's Westboro & Franklin. Grafton's I think 2 minutes longer.
It cracked us up, b/c the realtor in Duxbury actually apologized for including a house that was *gasp* on "only" a half acre!!! Just try and afford anything on a half acre close in! But I digress.
The downside to Hingham is the rediculously out of control housing costs. I know, I know, supply & demand, I've got it. But I'm seriously starting to think even in this so-called buyer's market we're not going to be able to get anything for less than $800 that doesn't need renovating. Not "updating", not just a shiny new fridge and some wallpaper, but flat out RENOVATING.
Our range is 550-650, could *maybe* stretch to 700 if we had to (there goes any furniture, upgrading, etc.). In Franklin that buys you a McMansion (if that's your thing) and in Hingham, well, go to realtor.com .
We saw aout 35 houses in 3 days in Hingham, Duxbury, North/South/West/Northboro, Holliston, Hopkinton, Shrewsbury, and I think I'm forgetting somewhere, but the only house we saw that we both (key word
BOTH!) felt that "this is the house!!" feeling was in Northboro for $729...well beyond our range.
There are plenty of metrowest houses in our range, just kind of disappointed that we can't pick up our house here and move it to MA.
Sorry for all the negativity, I'm just bummed.
On the POSITIVE side, everyone we encountered was incredibly friendly, nice, helpful, it was AMAZING. There are some stories there for another post.

I don't know what they're talking about with these unfriendly newenglander posts.
Best of luck! Hope I haven't bummed you out too much.