|
A Honda Civic will probably do fine in Montana in the winter. A lot of people think that trucks work better. The advantage a Honda has is they are front wheel drive cars so they get pretty darn good traction. A lot of trucks (2WD) are rear wheel drive so they don't get good traction without a load of dirt in the back, so they slide all over the place. Also remember that all vehicles are 4 wheel braking so they'll all stop pretty similiar on roads - the big old Hummers don't stop faster than a little Honda Civic on icy roads. They both slide around a lot.
The other thing to consider is you really don't need engine power on icy roads in the winter. Usually people get stuck because the wheels are spinning - in which case your engine is providing much more power than your wheels can deliver to the road. Engine power helps you go up a steep hill at 65 while pulling a trailer, but is close to useless when your stuck in a snowbank. So for most people, buying a set of studded snow tires would be a good move. Really your best defense in winter driving conditions is to drive slowly and carefully. By driving slow, careful, and defensively, you'll avoid far more accidents than you will by buying a big old honking truck.
On the flip side, trucks do have an advantage that their tires sometimes are more aggressive, they are often 4WD, and they are heavier. But I grew up in a family with both cars and trucks, and I found I could take the little Honda Prelude just about anywhere in winter driving.
|