I have to agree as well about Bloomfield, then Montclair, Caldwell, and Verona in that order but only IF you can find something for 900.
DO consider looking at rentals that are slightly higher than your price range. If you really like the place, make an offer.
I worked in Real Estate (but
not as an agent) and when the rental inventory is high, rentals sit around for weeks, or months without the landlord collecting any rental income and they really hate that! You may not know how long the rental has been available (or how desperate the LL may be) but it's worth a shot. If the rental is very new, this method probably won't work. Otherwise try looking at rentals up to say maybe 1000/mo and you might get it for 900 (if you ask)!
It may still be in Bloomfield. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
Good Luck in your search!
