Report: The NYPD Is Failing Vision Zero: Gothamist
The NYPD is failing to adequately police reckless drivers even as cyclist deaths and pedestrian and cyclist injuries climb, according to a report issued today by Transportation Alternatives [
PDF].
Between January and May of this year, 5,588 pedestrians and cyclists were injured in traffic, up 11.6% from the same period last year. Pedestrian deaths have decreased in the same period—46, down from 51—and cyclist deaths have doubled: 14, up from seven.
There have been 22 fatal hit-and-run crashes this year, up from 14 at this time in 2015.
Summonses for speeding and failure to yield—two offenses that often factor into a serious crash—were up between January and May of this year. Department records show that cops issued 18,993 summonses for speeding and 16,461 for failing to yield between January and May, increases of 15.3% and 16.5% for the same months, respectively, in 2015.
But today's report suggests that on the precinct level, some officers seem to be prioritizing the wrong infractions. In Brownsville, for example, cops issued 1,257 summonses for tinted windows between January and May, compared to 85 for failure to yield. In 32 precincts, officers issued more tickets for tinted windows than for speeding and failure to yield combined.
Other precincts are devoting "disproportionate resources" to cracking down on cyclists, according to the report's authors. Although the NYPD started issuing moving violations for riding on the sidewalk in 2014, criminal summonses outnumbered the less-consequential violations 1,858 to 1,655 last year. In the 79th Precinct in Bed-Stuy, cops issued 146 criminal summonses for sidewalk riding, compared to 2 moving violations.
And when a hit-and-run driver
struck and killed cyclist Matthew von Ohlen as he rode in a Williamsburg bike lane earlier this month—cops have said the driver may have done so intentionally—locals noted an uptick in
red light and jaywalking tickets.
"Data-driven enforcement is a part Vision Zero, but the NYPD is not doing data-driven policing," said Transportation Alternatives Director Paul Steely White. "Instead they are policing by some historic bias that I don't understand."
In some precincts, an increase in summonses has lead to a decrease in crashes this year. In the 5th Precinct, covering Chinatown, speeding summonses more than doubled in early 2016, and injuries dropped 5%. In the 111th Precinct, covering Bayside and Fresh Meadows in Queens, speeding summonses increased 52% and failure to yield summonses 42%, with injuries down 15%.
"Speeding and failure to yield pose the greatest risk to pedestrians, cyclists and drivers," mayoral spokesman Austin Finan said. "Our enforcement efforts are laser-focused on reducing these dangerous driving behaviors and making our streets safer for everyone."
However, 17 precincts, primarily in Manhattan and Queens, saw a decrease in speeding tickets in early 2016. In Manhattan North as a whole, speeding summonses are down 19%.
"The variability in ticketing practices as shown by this data indicates that there is no unified, citywide
Vision Zero policy and protocol," Transportation Alternatives writes. "Consistent, predictable enforcement is most likely to have the deterrent effect that changes behavior and saves lives."
To address cyclist safety issues, this year the NYPD has launched an initiative called
Bicycle Safe Passage. For four-day stretches in May and June, precincts across the city cracked down on drivers blocking bike lanes, as well as those who failed to yield to pedestrians. More than 800 failure to yield tickets were issued in June, as well as 1,086 red light tickets and 1,757 tickets for blocking a bike lane.
Mayor de Blasio called 2015 the
"safest year ever" on NYC streets, with 134 pedestrians killed, versus 139 in 2014 and 183 in 2013.
"We've regularized enforcement of the most dangerous driving behaviors, and the numbers bear that fact out across the board," said Finan, the mayor's spokesman.
Transportation Alternatives called the Safe Passage initiative a "welcome, if short-term and occasional, move," adding that the data doesn't include breakdowns by precinct. It also doesn't indicate whether cops are focusing on the most dangerous streets and intersections.
"We're not asking for more enforcement or summonsing in general. We're asking for more precise summonsing of the most egregious infractions," said Steely White. "This is a sharp contrast from enforcement activity that's based on suspicion or bias."
Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
