curlybelle, for about 2 years now, I have been slowly planning my exit from upstate NY. The people here are great, but I think I can sniff out wonderful folks no matter where I land. The scenery is definitely some of the nicest I've seen anywhere - and I've been making a lot of trips to come to that conclusion & aid in my decision. The northeast has so many positives going for it; but for me the two negatives of NY - taxes & winter - has me looking elsewhere.
You didn't say how old you are, but since you are still unencumbered, you can always move back to NJ/NY if things don't pan out. Why not plan a road-trip vacation? Pick a region that offers you all those things you listed in your OP, and explore! Just from what I've found; coastal properties & towns are too expensive for most unless your job pays really, really well. But you can still find a place that's an hour or two from the beach - not so bad, eh?
A friend of mine was looking for pretty much everything you've listed. He wound up in Georgia. He gets four seasons, but winter there is really just heavy-jacket weather; & a lot shorter, IMO. He's not far from the beach when he needs his fix.
I grew up out west (CO) & loved it. But I'm older now & looking for a slow comfortable, laid back way of life. I just think you should take advantage of the job you have now & use your vacation time to physically visit a region of the country that offers what you seek.
C-D has been a great help to me in opening my eyes to what else is out there. Have you checked out any of the picture threads? I saw one & it spurred me to visit Tennessee....which is now at the top of my relocation list!
Best of luck to you!
