I personally wouldn't put my children in West Schools primarily because there are such better alternatives.
When we moved to York 4 years ago from a major city, schools was my number one priority. We have 4 kids.

Dallastown, Suburban and Central were our top picks. I found alot of houses in West York that I really liked, but after talking to many people about the schools in that area, my husband and I decided on Dallastown. We live right on the border of Suburban, off the Queen Street exit off 83. That would be a EASY commute to work for you: 83N to 30E. The houses in our area have lots of Colonial Charm, built by the doctors of York Hospital years ago, so quality construction. We love the area and wouldn't trade our 40 year old quality built home and Dallastown school district for a new home for ANYTHING!
Good luck on your house hunting trip!