Which of these rings do you think would be a better deal? (prices, selling)

[lovesMountains]

Originally Posted by Kleenex

Options:

#1 .58 Ct, colorless (F), I(1), round set in white gold $1800 after taxes

#2 .50 Ct, colorless (F), I(1), round set in white gold $1400 after taxes

#3 .48 Ct, nearcolorless (H), I(2), round set in white gold $1000 after taxes


All are certified.

one from Kay, one from Shaws, one from Zeals

Those all sound pretty similar and not too expensive for an engagment ring - go with the one that is most appealing to you based on looks alone

[Jill61]

With your attitude, I pick "move on".

Have a nice life.

[Raena77]

Originally Posted by Jill61

With your attitude, I pick "move on".

Have a nice life.

Ditto!

[Kleenex]

Originally Posted by Jill61

With your attitude, I pick "move on".

Have a nice life.

Originally Posted by Raena77

Ditto!

Wonderful!!!!!




now that the ones who can't answer a simple 'multiple choice' question have left the room, can someone please give me some advice on the 3 mentioned choices?

thank you in advance.

[lovesMountains]

Originally Posted by Kleenex

Wonderful!!!!!




now that the ones who can't answer a simple 'multiple choice' question have left the room, can someone please give me some advice on the 3 mentioned choices?

thank you in advance.

But I already did

Really, they are so similar, why not go with the one you like based on its looks alone??

[dvcgal]

#1!!! The bigger the better!!!

[dvcgal]

I like princess cut or emerald! It's a personal choice but those are two that I am partial to! If anyone wants to send me a gift for X-mas! lol!

[yellowsnow]

Buy one you can afford that you think she will like. That's what's important.

Here's the why's, wherefore's, and the skinny on the jewelry business. Profit on average purchases in a jewelry store is an exorbitant 700%, more or less. Engagement rings are usually one of the higher profit items. It's not likely you are going to get a deal these days. Gold is very high right now too. That's why I said buy what you can afford. The chances of you getting a 'deal' are about as likely as snow in Key West!

[Kleenex]

Originally Posted by lovesMountains

But I already did

Really, they are so similar, why not go with the one you like based on its looks alone??

Thanks.

I know what you mean.....actually, the one that's 1000 (#3) is the prettiest one! i don't know why but it's the shiniest of them all and if i don't put them side by side, its size seems nice and big. (that's what she said)
so i may just go with option #3. i just don't know why a 'near colorless' would look shinier than a 'colorless F'?!!! maybe the lighting at the store?!

[STT Resident]

Totally a random thought on my part but have you considered maybe perhaps asking the women you're planning on proposing to which SHE likes best?