I am nowhere near you right now and growing up on LI, we got snow almost every year anda decent shot of snow every other year with occasional blizzards sprinkled in in my high school/college years but I have to suggest TORO brand. My parents bought this blower years ago (1991 maybe). They moved and I got it. My fiancee is still in NY working while I am working in FL so I leave it in her garage for myself and the neighbor to use depending on when I am there but this little TORO (4.5 hp CCR 2000 series 2 cycle has to be almost 15 years old and has seen its fair share of snow and ice storms in those 15 years. 94-96 was blizzard and ice storm central for us. Once again, nothing like Syracuse will get but I have to say with regular maintenance and replacement of worn parts, and one carb job on it last year, it starts on the first pull. Just got it goin a few weeks ago to warm it up. Highly recommend Toro. (
www.toro.com) Go to their website and you can bring up a list of dealers in the area as well as models. I agree too go with smaller dealers who are more knowledgeable and where you will feel good about the purchase.
Not sure if metal vs. plastic augers (can't spell that) is an option on bigger machines or even recommended in the snow belt. Previous poster's suggestion of John Deeres and Craftman series are also a good bet. THey have reliable and decent models available. Not sure if older vs. newer is better or worse but I do beleive they don't make things like they used to anymore. Things are not really made to be repaired anymore...throw away and buy new. I swear by Toro though...even my mower is Toro.
Good luck
PS. My grandfather has an Ariens...not really sure how that works out for him but its a big metal beast and he is 85 and he pushes that around to clear his driveway (AGainst our advice). Has not told me any issues so I guess its ok.
EDIT: Go to the homeowners tab on the left side of the website and click on snow throwers and it will bring up their two model series. I also did a quick check of the syracuse area, not sure of zip so i used 13220 and I got 5 in the area:
NORTH SYRACUSE POWERHOUSE
440 B SOUTH BAY ROAD, NORTH SYRACUSE, NY, US, 13212
Phone: (315) 458-2121 Fax: (315) 458-2099
Services Toro products regardless of where purchased.
OUTDOOR POWER EQUIPMENT,
5280 CAUGHDENOY RD, CLAY, NY, US, 13041
Phone: (315) 699-2838 Fax: (315) 699-9780
Master Service Dealer.
Services Toro products regardless of where purchased.
CENTRAL NEW YORK POWER EQUIP INC
7989 OSWEGO RD, LIVERPOOL, NY, US, 13090
Phone: (315) 652-5734 Fax: (315) 652-3314
Services Toro products regardless of where purchased.
MIKE'S POWER EQUIPMENT
1841 W FAYETTE ST, SYRACUSE, NY, US, 13204
Phone: (315) 488-0921 Fax: (315) 488-5608
WEST GENESEE SALES
2522 W GENESEE ST, SYRACUSE, NY, US, 13204
Phone: (315) 468-4011 Fax: (315) 468-4057
The second is considered a MASTER SERVICE DEALER. I equate that probably to like Chryslers 5-star dealership award probably. Good luck.