American Idol 2011 (ratings, shows, house, parents)

[Sunny-Days-in-Florida]

Originally Posted by Jill61

Not so fast yourself.

An honest review of my lists from week to week will show that the contestants moved up and down all over the place on the list, as each list was reflective of that show only.

And I'm certain my supposed "original" list (since you didn't bother to link to the post where that list came from) was based on the audition performances the producers had bothered to show us to that point, as opposed to seeing them in actual competition mode singing "full" songs week after week.

Naima sank like a stone on my list almost immediately once that part of the show started. So you can hardly admonish me with your "not so fast" nonsense based on that list.

Are you saying this is not your list?

Come on Jill be honest you know this was your list.

Here is your precious link to show Haley was NOT on your list and not one of your favs since the start like you said. I bothered to make sure the link is here so even you will know who you pick and WHO YOU DID not and try to lay claim as you the one who picked Haley from the start when it is clear from your list and link she was not even in your top 13.

American Idol 2011

This is suppose to be all in fun but goodness to come back and pretend like your list did not exist and that I just made it up out of the blue is borderline dishonest.

[Sunny-Days-in-Florida]

Originally Posted by wojtekm

I wanna see Snop Dog in a judges team of next American Idol ;p




______________________________________________
Everything you can imagin, can be real!
Digital Imag(e)ination
PHOTO RETOUCH-RESTORATION,retouching faces,old picture repair,digital image fix
Professional photo retouching and restoration design

For real?

Another no talent hack showing these kids what to do.

Amazing.

[Isitmeorarethingsnuts?]

Haley was the pick of Vote For the Worst but I'm not sure how much pull they have. It's my opinion that she got a lot of sympathy votes from James fans and everyone thought he would be safe.

[Flamingomo]

Originally Posted by sophialee

Yeah I like the show a lot too. I've watched every single season and every year people freak out and say the show is fixed when their favorite goes home. I'm a little over these new judges tho, not as people, I like them well enough, but as judges.

I've been saying the show is fixed for weeks/months. Casey should never have gone home before Jacob or Haley. And he was certainly not my favorite. I think he was great and more talented than them, but he should still be standing. I have seen bits and pieces of other seasons too. And seriously, you are going to try and say it wasn't fixed last year when Adam Lambert was sent packing and whats his name won? Thats funny. I'm not even a fan of his but he should have won that hands down. He is way more talented than the other guy.

It is obvious from so many angles the show is not based on fan voting. Anyone can see that.

[LoveBoating]

TOTAL, ABSOLUTE SHOCK to see James leave last night! He's a "Rocker", no doubt about that and does a GREAT job of it! Even though he didn't make it to the Top 3, I sure hopes he's invited to do a duo with Steven Tyler......Walk This Way or Dream On would be great to hear from them. Even though James left, this dude is going to be a BIG rock star......no doubt about it!!
About Haley making it into the Top 3, only one thing we can say.....absolutely NO COMMENT or should we say
Lauren should win this who thing, but what will we all say if Haley does???
As for Scotty, he's got a shot at it, but we think Lauren is the one and SHOULD be the one to win
Now, question is, if winning AI makes a person a star, what happened to that dude that won last year???? Crystal came in 2nd last season and performed on AI and done a commercial with BB King, but what about that dude that won?? And, whatever happened to Casey James from last season......he was a "Rocker" as well.

[Nea1]

Just saw it on the news ( I stopped watching after Casey went home), now I am totally convinced of either two things. The show is rigged or AI voters are tone deaf.

[Jill61]

Originally Posted by jazznblues

I disagree that Haley has more range. I think she runs out of steam easily and it turns into a scream or yell (like her first song Wednesday). Lauren's voice has and effortless quality. Haley is all over the map singing - and that isn't because she is versatile. It's because she doesn't know what she is.

This is such an absurd allegation. Haley is a bluesy jazz POP singer. Anyone who hasn't picked up on that either hasn't been paying attention or has been buying the crap the judges are spoon feeding them.

Maybe not every "theme" week has an option she can turn into something bluesy, but that hardly means she doesn't know what she is.


YouTube - Haley Reinhart - House of the Rising Sun
Randy Jackson: "The best performance of the night goes to Haley."


YouTube - Haley Reinhart - Benny and the Jets
Randy Jackson: "Best performance of the night right there."


YouTube - Haley Reinhart - Rollin' in the Deep
Randy Jackson: "You chose a perfect direction for you."


YouTube - Haley Reinhart - Beautiful

[goodgal]

Originally Posted by Georgianbelle

Who could not have felt sorry for James? It was sad to see him go, but he sounded bitter when he said he had done things on AI this year that no one else had ever done. What has he done that is better than everyone else? IMO nothing.

James actions are his Asperger's in motion. Not filtering his spoken words. I find it unbelievable that he doesn't realize AI is just the beginning and lots of good things will be coming his way. I think he convinced himself he had it in the bag and was in shock. Haley also comes across (as another poster suggested earlier) as someone with a slight Asperger profile. She has something "off" about her JMO

[colleeng47]

Originally Posted by RD5050

I'll bet the judges are now wishing they hadn't used their one and only "save" so early in the competition.

I thought that too, but then I'm sure they would have used it to save Pia.

[Flamingomo]

Originally Posted by Jill61

This is such an absurd allegation. Haley is a bluesy jazz POP singer. Anyone who hasn't picked up on that either hasn't been paying attention or has been buying the crap the judges are spoon feeding them.

Maybe not every "theme" week has an option she can turn into something bluesy, but that hardly means she doesn't know what she is.

James and Scotty seem to have no problem adjusting their genre to the theme weeks . Haley just isn't that good to do it.