American Idol 2011 (Lost, Arizona, Texas, music)

[_redbird_]

I think any young singer should at least listen to constructive criticism. You could tell by the look on her face, Haley, just did not want to hear it.

Oh well.

Now, she doesn't have to hear it anymore.

And to be honest, there were a couple of times when I thought WOW, that Haley can sing! Then, her tude came.

None of us old fogies will ever agree with AI's voters. Such is life. I wish her the best. She is unshackled by not being the winner of AI.

[Sun Thinker]

Originally Posted by njsocks

Ah! The raspy phlegm ball is going home! Thank you God!! Buh Bye!

I absolutely loved the reaction on the face! Priceless! The jaw dropped about 200 feet!

The remaining two are great. I don't care who wins now!

Haley will do well in her career, very well. She quite possibly has much more class than many of her detractors.

I like Haley's talent and voice. I care not for anything else.

[_redbird_]

Originally Posted by Beretta

Thanks for debating the issue and not each other. Please remember no personal attacks. For the most part you guys have been AWESOME posters!!! Thanks!

I agree. It's normal for us all to have our favorites. I do not bear any grudges. It is a tv show and we laugh at it all after it's over.

Randy and his Toon Town jacket last week made me laugh.

I don't think Steven Tyler will come back. He is a performer first and foremost.

I liked JLo. She has a gig, so we won't see her either.

[Sun Thinker]

Originally Posted by _redbird_

I think any young singer should at least listen to constructive criticism. You could tell by the look on her face, Haley, just did not want to hear it.

Oh well.

Now, she doesn't have to hear it anymore.

And to be honest, there were a couple of times when I thought WOW, that Haley can sing! Then, her tude came.

None of us old fogies will ever agree with AI's voters. Such is life. I wish her the best. She is unshackled by not being the winner of AI.

I agree with you, her attitude is a turnoff, even if an intangible. But her talent is unmistakably at a higher level. I like Lauren and Scotty, probably Lauren better. But their niches aren't as picky as the rest of the genres out there.

Haley could truly be a huge star.

[Beretta]

Originally Posted by _redbird_

I think any young singer should at least listen to constructive criticism. You could tell by the look on her face, Haley, just did not want to hear it.

Oh well.

Now, she doesn't have to hear it anymore.

And to be honest, there were a couple of times when I thought WOW, that Haley can sing! Then, her tude came.

None of us old fogies will ever agree with AI's voters. Such is life. I wish her the best. She is unshackled by not being the winner of AI.

Spot on post! With 95 Million votes it was crazy! I would be interested in knowing the stats on the votes.

[R_Cowgirl]

Just signing in from Arizona, avoiding earlier posts about winners, but I just have to say... DANG! Those Italian singers are amazing!!! Kinda gives you a different view of our three teenagers, yes? What lungs! The one in the middle is yummy! And I like that one of them is kinda geeky. What amazing voices!!! WHEW! WOW.

[Sun Thinker]

Originally Posted by Beretta

Spot on post! With 95 Million votes it was crazy! I would be interested in knowing the stats on the votes.

The only votes that really count, are the sales over the next decade. The music industry has been consistently wrong for decades. They just don't get it.

[Who?Me?!]

Ba-ba-ba BYE Haley! you nasty mouth banshee!!!

Those hard eyed looks and foul mouth are GONE!


Great to see two NICE kids making it through!!! And they both sing a thousand times better than HaleyTheScreech.

[SunnyKayak]

Originally Posted by _redbird_

I think any young singer should at least listen to constructive criticism. You could tell by the look on her face, Haley, just did not want to hear it.

Oh well.

Now, she doesn't have to hear it anymore.

And to be honest, there were a couple of times when I thought WOW, that Haley can sing! Then, her tude came.

None of us old fogies will ever agree with AI's voters. Such is life. I wish her the best. She is unshackled by not being the winner of AI.

old fogie, I thought these gray hairs was just seasoning

I really felt Haley did a awesome job last night except the Alanis Morrisette song. Some stated we will not hear from her after this week maybe not to much radio wise after a year from now who knows, but she was the most beautiful of the season she will probably end up on entertainment show co-host or reporter.

I kinda want Lauren to win so that Scotty isnt shackled by AI like you said, this way he can have more freedom choosing the right country music producer in Nashville and not Hollywood.

As about all seasons except for two the best singer ends up runner up.
Is it because it fixed or two much confident in who should be the winner that the next to best ends up with more votes.

[kahncss]

I too loved ll Volo! Talk about talent!

Originally Posted by Ecovlke

I'm disgusted. I would buy Haley's music. I wouldn't even listen to Lauren or Scotty on the radio. I definitely will not be tuning in for the finale.

That's it. I'm breaking up with American Idol for the last time.

I think Haley will have a great career and sell much music. Lauren will fall flat. Scotty will be fine with country. He fits right in. Same ole' same ole' boring chit.

Ya, ya, ya. We've heard that before. I must say, this year was probably the worst one ever.

Originally Posted by njsocks

ROFL @ Wai-lee!
Exactly. She is all for herself. Nobody else. No one likes Haley more than Haley herself!

Except, maybe her daddyo!

Originally Posted by _redbird_

I think any young singer should at least listen to constructive criticism. You could tell by the look on her face, Haley, just did not want to hear it.

Oh well.

Now, she doesn't have to hear it anymore.

And to be honest, there were a couple of times when I thought WOW, that Haley can sing! Then, her tude came.

None of us old fogies will ever agree with AI's voters. Such is life. I wish her the best. She is unshackled by not being the winner of AI.

Tried to rep you.