American Idol (opening, show)

[christina0001]

I thought they'd vote out 2 girls and 2 guys again.

[corruption]

I believe it's 2 guys 2 girls till they get the top 12.

AMANDA NEEDS TO GO.

That performance was horrible. Everyone else was roses compared to her!

I for one loved Syesha's perfomance. Artists have always done gender bending songs. I saw nothing wrong with it.

Overall the girls weren't that great this week.

[austinsmom]

Originally Posted by acors

Brooke really surprised me tonight. Her performance was really great, and she looked less like a ghastly ghost this week. Amazing what a little hair gel and spray, and a make up artist can do! She was the best by a mile tonight! I really liked her a lot!
Ramiele was good but her song choice was awful, I like how she's so tiny with a great big voice but tonight's song did nothing in her favor. She's ok but I'm not getting the reason everyone loves her so much b/c she's petite....who cares????
Carly, I don't understand what the hype is about her...she seems mediocre, like people have mentioned she had a chance to record already and had an album out, people didn't dig it then and I don't think people are going to dig it now. She's not the next Chris Daughtry, the way people seem to be treating her. I thought she was good.
Amanda needs to tame that hair! Her voice was awful, the song was awful, everything was just awful. Couldn't agree more here and I wanted to like it.
Alaina I expected more from her...but I want her to have another chance. She seems sweet and innocent. Hated the blue dress. I thought she did great and looked beautiful. Too many of these people come out looking like they just got out of bed. It's nice to see someone dressed nice for a change.
Alexandrea, I cannot wait to see this girl go home! Her interview video felt like it was just a way to sell herself rather than answer the question like all the other 19 contestants. There's a time and place to brag, that interview segment wasn't it. Can't even remember what she sang.
Kady, I think she's staying in this competition solely based on looks and popularity. Obviously she's a popular girl and has tons of hometown support, but her talent is seriously lacking. Just another pretty face and a decent voice, but nothing destined for superstardom. She should try out for SNL guest spot as a impersonator, she is SO much better at that than she is of actually singing her own style. Song was good but she annoys me. Only in it b/c she's pretty.
Asia'h was a disappointment this week. I agreed with Simon, the song was just too big for her. Didn't like it.
Syesha, for some reason I have just never been into her performances, I think her voice is good but I definitely don't agree with how psyched Paula is about this girl. Her performance tonight was completely forgettable, in fact so much so that I have no idea what she sang and the show just ended! I agree. I don't get her appeal at all. I didn't like that she changed the song either. Some songs are easy for either gender to sing. Mrs. Jones should not have to be changed to Mr. Jones. There are too many songs to choose from to do that.

Are they picking 1 girl 1 boy or 2 girls 2 boys to leave this week?

I hope it's Syesha (probably Asia'h) and Alexandrea for the girls and Jason Y and Chickeze (will probably be Luke) for the boys. I think I have a 50 / 50 shot at getting my wish.

[MooksterL1]

I think this is the season for the guys. The girls are not as memorable to me. In fact, I was reading the posts on here and trying to think which one was Alaina. I do like Carly, Ramiele and Brook, but anyone else leaving is fine with me. I liked Amanda until last night, but it was just bad and I'm not even including her Bride of Frankenstein hair.

[SuziSu]

who sang that "what goes up must come down" song? I liked her.

[corruption]

No doubt about it AMANDA is the one who sounded like a gutted pig. She's the one going home.

[collected_eve]

When David Archuleta sang on Tues. I had a few tears. It was a moving performance. I'm all for him at this point & Ramiele M. Those are the only 2 that really do it for me this year.

[eggalegga]

I've watched AI since day one. Last night was boring in my opinion. I was so disappointed. I wanted them all to do better. I will say that Amanda's performance was the worst, but I don't know who did the best. It's the year for a guy to win.

[RAZZEL]

David Archuleta is excellent.

Good voice
Humble
Cute
Personable

A sure winner!!!!!!!

[acors]

I was SO sad tonight for Alaina! Unbelieveable.