Project Runway All Stars Season 6 Premieres Jan 4th (actor, friends, Cary)

[easternerDC]

Again - for real - how is Merline not sent home. Her dress was f-ugly, ill-made, and not young or fresh or hip.

Not that either of the other bottom two were good, but seriously? How is she not gone.

[PippySkiddles]

Originally Posted by easternerDC

Again - for real - how is Merline not sent home. Her dress was f-ugly, ill-made, and not young or fresh or hip.

Not that either of the other bottom two were good, but seriously? How is she not gone.

does make one wonder..........

[KaraG]

Can't believe Josh won and Merline is still there. I liked his tee but hated the skirt/granny panty contraption. Ugly.

[GracieKarm]

All the outfits were ugly. And the judges must be wanting Merline to win because I have no idea why they keep letting her stay. It's ridiculous.

[Alinka]

Not much to say about this episode.

Generally, I like Anthony, Fabio and Ken. This week was no exception. Anthony's white tissue dress was appealing to me. I thought Ken's gown was dramatic, and while Fabio's did not make a strong impression, I liked it.

Char, Kimberly or Merline could have gone home. It occurred to me that Candice got a lot of TH time, then poof- gone. It seemed like the same happened with Amanda and this week with Char.

[veuvegirl]

Originally Posted by easternerDC

Again - for real - how is Merline not sent home. Her dress was f-ugly, ill-made, and not young or fresh or hip.

Not that either of the other bottom two were good, but seriously? How is she not gone.

Exactly! Baffled.

[mauialoha]

I agree with the preceding posts and I was most bummed when they sent Amanda home instead of Gerline. I thought Amandas fabric was beautiful. Judges didn't like the fit but I thought it looked like an informal sort of shift dress.(supposed to be loose fitting)

Also, am I the only one who finds Anne Fulenwider's comments annoying and not helpful at all to the designers? I mean, she just seems to want to come out with a one liner like "I'm getting Pippi Longstocking from this"

[veuvegirl]

Originally Posted by mauialoha

I agree with the preceding posts and I was most bummed when they sent Amanda home instead of Gerline. I thought Amandas fabric was beautiful. Judges didn't like the fit but I thought it looked like an informal sort of shift dress.(supposed to be loose fitting)

Also, am I the only one who finds Anne Fulenwider's comments annoying and not helpful at all to the designers? I mean, she just seems to want to come out with a one liner like "I'm getting Pippi Longstocking from this"

Yes! Anne is awful. She doesn’t help them creatively whatsoever.

[easternerDC]

So last week, I thought FOR SURE the judges would ding Merline for creating almost the same exact dress yet again. But there we go with her being in the top.

And this weeks episode, Merline seemed SHOCKED when whats-her-face the worst mentor in PR all-stars history tells her not to do the same thing again. For a moment I thought for sure they would keep Merline over Anthony. Thankfully, all is well in the universe and it ended well. But it was tense for a minute.

Noone else has posted in a while, any other thoughts?

[N.Cal]

So glad Merline is finally gone. I think most of the designs this week were good. Stanley is really coming into his own in the last couple of episodes. At the beginning, I wasn't sure about him.