So You Think You Can Dance ~ 2009 (show, favorite, Dallas, live)

[whatnow]

Forgot this earlier - when Kat asked the judges at the end of the show who they thought would win, I thought: 1) it was a tacky question and I have to assume it was "in the script"; 2) Adam and Mary gave very kind, diplomatic answers; and 3) Nigel, as power for his course, gave a sucky answer. So, there! ha-ha!!
The way Nigel has been acting, I was thinking that maybe he got fired starting next season and that is why he's making such crude comments. Or is this typical behavior for him. I DO understand critiquing, but it seems he has crossed some lines.
And picking on Evan so much these past few weeks on his looks was just ashame. It would be like picking on Kayla week after week for being a bottle-blonde!

[tigerlily]

Originally Posted by max's mama

Okay - question:
Why were the judges reluclant to criticize Kayla's solo but ripped Evan's apart??? Isn't it a little misleading??
Yeah, let's NOT talk about the solo, but talk about the entire season with Kayla, but when it comes to Evan, let's criticize him to death.

I love Jeanine. She is beautiful, extremely talented, has a great down-to earth personality and I want her to win sooooo freaking bad.

I don't know why, but Kayla from the very beginning was getting on my nerves tremendously!!! When last week Jeanine accidentally hit her in the face, I said: she deserves to be smacked in the face. I know it's so awful of me...but I just can't stand her personality.


So, if it's not Jeanine, it's better be Brandon.

The judges call her "white lightning", I call her the "ice queen". Janine's solo last night was far superior to Kayla's. I did a double take when she pirouetted. Jeanine and Janette both have great charisma. Brandon and Janine should be the last two standing. I think Evan should have been eliminated several weeks ago, but I'm sick of them making remarks about his face. If his brother makes top twenty next season, are we going to have a redux on the face remarks?

[westhou]

The opening number was weird!

Cat looks great!

[JaasNYC]

Cat is a hot ticket. And she seems genuinely down to earth.

[westhou]

Originally Posted by JaasNYC

Cat is a hot ticket. And she seems genuinely down to earth.

She deserves an Emmy for best host. She is amazing.

[senalj]

Does anyone else think Debbie Allen needs to check the cut of her blouse? I have no problems with cleavage (and am by no stretch of the imagination a prude), but I felt she showed a little too much!


*****SPOILER ALERT*****



4. Kayla
3. Evan
2. Brandon
1. Jeanine

I'm okay with that. I liked both of the top 2. I'm a little surprised, because I thought for sure Brandon's fan base (females) would put him over the top, but am happy the girls are catching up!

[veuvegirl]

Kat looked great! The judges dancing was lame. And the dark horse won! Thought it was good, not great, but good.

[westhou]

Originally Posted by senalj

Does anyone else think Debbie Allen needs to check the cut of her blouse? I have no problems with cleavage (and am by no stretch of the imagination a prude), but I felt she showed a little too much!


*****SPOILER ALERT*****



4. Kayla
3. Evan
2. Brandon
1. Jeanine

I'm okay with that. I liked both of the top 2. I'm a little surprised, because I thought for sure Brandon's fan base (females) would put him over the top, but am happy the girls are catching up!

I'm glad she won too. I would have preferred Kayla to win but I'm glad it's a girl this year.

I just wish that Kayla would move on to Dancing with the Stars as a dance trainer. She would shine on there.

[ajzjmsmom]

I am so glad Janine won, I thought she did a really good job with just about everything that was handed to her.

[westhou]

It was good to see Jeanette again.