Well I have to make a decision pretty soon. My Nissan Sentra is 20 years old, but it is reliable. I think the pickup could be better, though.
Now is a great time to buy a new car, because of the time of year and because of the state of the economy.
My concern, mainly, is FWD vs AWD. I rarely, if ever, to off-road driving, although I could easily, up here, drive on dirt roads. My main concern is traction on slippery roads, althugh handling and braking are up there too.. AWD is great, but is it necessary and worth the sacrifices in terms of cost, maintenance and inferior fuel economy?
The only AWD I have been considering is a Subaru - probably a Legacy, but possibly an Impreza. I want a sedan that hides what's in the trunk, not a station wagon or Forester that shows it. Remember, I'd be driving this car into NYC on occasion! If I really need the cargo space I guess I can rent something or pay someone with a truck.
Although I love Hondas - I drove an Accord for about 9 years - I'm concerned that a new Honda Civic or Accord would get stolen in NYC. I've been told, though, that the ones that get stolen are the models from, I think, the late 90's.
People love their Priuses, but I have read that they don't handle as well as some other cars. I don't know anythng about their traction.
So for me, I think it boils down to a Subaru (Legacy or Impreza) or a Honda (Civic or Accord). Maybe a Honda hybrid, since I may end up commuting to Keene, Northampton, Bellows Falls, Springfield or the Upper Valley for work. It would be nice to save money, especially after what I have been paying for Sammy's care.
There are also potential night time dashes, in bad weather, to South Deerfield for veterinary emergencies.