Property valuation of East 53 Street, Manhattan, NY: 411 #9D, 411 #9E, 411 #9F, 411 #9G, 411 #9H, 411 #9J, 411 #9K, 411 #9L, 411 #9M, 411 #10A (tax assessments)
Other nearby streets: East 53 Street (1) 
East 53 Street (2)
East 53 Street (3)
East 53 Street (4)
East 53 Street (5)
East 53 Street (2)
East 53 Street (3)
East 53 Street (4)
East 53 Street (5)
Listed properties vs overall distribution of properties in Manhattan, NY:
Advertisements
411 East 53 Street #9D
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: 53 ASSOCIATES CO.
Current year's total market value of the land: $62,727
Current year's total market value of improvements: $213,554 (it was $190,154 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $276,281 (it was $252,881 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $28,227
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $88,764
Current transitional assessed total value: $116,991
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,228
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $93,946
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,174
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,228
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $93,946
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,174
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,353 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: 53 ASSOCIATES CO.
Current year's total market value of the land: $62,727
Current year's total market value of improvements: $213,554 (it was $190,154 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $276,281 (it was $252,881 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $28,227
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $88,764
Current transitional assessed total value: $116,991
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,228
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $93,946
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,174
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,228
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $93,946
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,174
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,353 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9E
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: CO-T BARRY H MANDEL
Current year's total market value of the land: $26,120
Current year's total market value of improvements: $88,931 (it was $79,187 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $115,051 (it was $105,307 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $11,754
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $36,959
Current transitional assessed total value: $48,713
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,754
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $39,118
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $50,872
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,754
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $39,118
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $50,872
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 563 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: CO-T BARRY H MANDEL
Current year's total market value of the land: $26,120
Current year's total market value of improvements: $88,931 (it was $79,187 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $115,051 (it was $105,307 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $11,754
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $36,959
Current transitional assessed total value: $48,713
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,754
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $39,118
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $50,872
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,754
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $39,118
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $50,872
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 563 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9F
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: LARISSA REZHETS
Current year's total market value of the land: $38,645
Current year's total market value of improvements: $131,569 (it was $117,153 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $170,214 (it was $155,798 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $17,390
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $54,684
Current transitional assessed total value: $72,074
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,390
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,877
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $75,267
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,390
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,877
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $75,267
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 833 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: LARISSA REZHETS
Current year's total market value of the land: $38,645
Current year's total market value of improvements: $131,569 (it was $117,153 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $170,214 (it was $155,798 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $17,390
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $54,684
Current transitional assessed total value: $72,074
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,390
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,877
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $75,267
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,390
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,877
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $75,267
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 833 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9G
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS STACY WEST CLARK
Current year's total market value of the land: $38,349
Current year's total market value of improvements: $130,578 (it was $116,271 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $168,927 (it was $154,620 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $17,257
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $54,274
Current transitional assessed total value: $71,531
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,257
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,441
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $74,698
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,257
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,441
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $74,698
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 836 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS STACY WEST CLARK
Current year's total market value of the land: $38,349
Current year's total market value of improvements: $130,578 (it was $116,271 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $168,927 (it was $154,620 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $17,257
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $54,274
Current transitional assessed total value: $71,531
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,257
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,441
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $74,698
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $17,257
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $57,441
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $74,698
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 836 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9H
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: MB-411, LLC
Current year's total market value of the land: $67,222
Current year's total market value of improvements: $228,933 (it was $203,850 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $296,155 (it was $271,072 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $30,250
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $95,155
Current transitional assessed total value: $125,405
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $30,250
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $100,710
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $130,960
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $30,250
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $100,710
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $130,960
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,450 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: MB-411, LLC
Current year's total market value of the land: $67,222
Current year's total market value of improvements: $228,933 (it was $203,850 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $296,155 (it was $271,072 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $30,250
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $95,155
Current transitional assessed total value: $125,405
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $30,250
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $100,710
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $130,960
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $30,250
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $100,710
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $130,960
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,450 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9J
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: FRANCISCA C REYES
Current year's total market value of the land: $25,122
Current year's total market value of improvements: $85,513 (it was $76,143 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $110,635 (it was $101,265 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $11,305
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $35,543
Current transitional assessed total value: $46,848
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,305
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $37,619
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $48,924
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,305
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $37,619
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $48,924
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 542 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: FRANCISCA C REYES
Current year's total market value of the land: $25,122
Current year's total market value of improvements: $85,513 (it was $76,143 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $110,635 (it was $101,265 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $11,305
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $35,543
Current transitional assessed total value: $46,848
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,305
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $37,619
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $48,924
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $11,305
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $37,619
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $48,924
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 542 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9K
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS CO-TRU JOYCE WEST
Current year's total market value of the land: $45,867
Current year's total market value of improvements: $156,167 (it was $139,056 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $202,034 (it was $184,923 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $20,640
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $64,910
Current transitional assessed total value: $85,550
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $20,640
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $68,700
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $89,340
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $20,640
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $68,700
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $89,340
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 989 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS CO-TRU JOYCE WEST
Current year's total market value of the land: $45,867
Current year's total market value of improvements: $156,167 (it was $139,056 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $202,034 (it was $184,923 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $20,640
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $64,910
Current transitional assessed total value: $85,550
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $20,640
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $68,700
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $89,340
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $20,640
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $68,700
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $89,340
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 989 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9L
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: FERRENA ALIDA
Current year's total market value of the land: $62,847
Current year's total market value of improvements: $213,973 (it was $190,527 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $276,820 (it was $253,374 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $28,281
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $88,938
Current transitional assessed total value: $117,219
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,281
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $94,130
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,411
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,281
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $94,130
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,411
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,355 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: FERRENA ALIDA
Current year's total market value of the land: $62,847
Current year's total market value of improvements: $213,973 (it was $190,527 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $276,820 (it was $253,374 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $28,281
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $88,938
Current transitional assessed total value: $117,219
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,281
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $94,130
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,411
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $28,281
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $94,130
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $122,411
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 1,355 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #9M
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS CO-T JANE A WEST
Current year's total market value of the land: $36,451
Current year's total market value of improvements: $124,098 (it was $110,501 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $160,549 (it was $146,952 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $16,403
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $51,581
Current transitional assessed total value: $67,984
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $16,403
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $54,591
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $70,994
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $16,403
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $54,591
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $70,994
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 780 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: AS CO-T JANE A WEST
Current year's total market value of the land: $36,451
Current year's total market value of improvements: $124,098 (it was $110,501 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $160,549 (it was $146,952 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $16,403
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $51,581
Current transitional assessed total value: $67,984
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $16,403
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $54,591
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $70,994
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $16,403
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $54,591
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $70,994
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 780 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
411 East 53 Street #10A
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: NI QIN
Current year's total market value of the land: $31,545
Current year's total market value of improvements: $107,446 (it was $95,674 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $138,991 (it was $127,219 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $14,195
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $44,655
Current transitional assessed total value: $58,850
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $14,195
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $47,263
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $61,458
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $14,195
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $47,263
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $61,458
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 680 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Manhattan, NY 10022
Find on map >>
Owner: NI QIN
Current year's total market value of the land: $31,545
Current year's total market value of improvements: $107,446 (it was $95,674 in 2012)
Current year's total market value: $138,991 (it was $127,219 in 2012)
Date of last change of market value: 05/01/2015
Current transitional assessed land value: $14,195
Current transitional assessed improvements value: $44,655
Current transitional assessed total value: $58,850
Tentative transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $14,195
Tentative transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $47,263
Tentative transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $61,458
Final transitional assessed land value for the next fiscal year: $14,195
Final transitional assessed improvements value for the next fiscal year: $47,263
Final transitional assessed total value for the next fiscal year: $61,458
Assessments for fiscal year: 2014/2015
Tax class: Apartments
Number of units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Number of residential units (condos, etc). in the building: 1
Irregularly shaped lot: no
Living area: 680 square feet
Irregularly shaped building: no
The number of stories for the building: 20.0
The number of buildings on the property: 1
The year the building was built: 1958
Other nearby streets: East 53 Street (1)
East 53 Street (2)
East 53 Street (3)
East 53 Street (4)
East 53 Street (5)
East 53 Street (2)
East 53 Street (3)
East 53 Street (4)
East 53 Street (5)
Recently Added Photos
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Manhattan, NY
Request disassociating your name from street-level assessment address
Recent home sales, price trends, and home value evaluator powered by Onboard Informatics
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
© 2024 Onboard Informatics. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Some parts © 2024 Advameg, Inc.
Compilation, repackaging, or reproduction prohibited. Users are forewarned that it is incumbent upon them to verify information with the responsible state agency. Advameg, Inc. does not guarantee the data presented is up-to-date nor does it assume responsibility for updating it. Therefore any names, owners or addresses may have changed. Use of any information published here to contact the persons might be prohibited by the law.