Quote:
Originally Posted by Texas User
Lot of injuries. Next year, this club can be even better then last year.
What do you think?
|
Unlikely. Let's quickly break it down by position
Catcher
2010: Molina (.6 WAR) Posey (3.8)
2012: Posey (4.5-5.0)
I'm not exactly sure what the prognosis for Posey's recovery is. I'd say 4.5-5.0 WAR from the position is a fair estimate for Posey coming back but maybe needing some time to get back into the swing of things.
First base
2010: Huff (3.6), Ishikawa (0)
2012: Belt?, Pill?, Huff? (2.0 total)
Who's going to play first? Huff is under contract, but Belt might be the better player. But Belt might not be the better player, he hasn't been impressive so far. However, Huff is a poor defensive OFer and much more useful at first.
Second base
2010: Sanchez (2.4)
2012: Sanchez (2.5)
Sanchez is also injured, and I haven't followed his injury that closely. 2-3 WAR is about what he's capable of producing.
Third base
2010: Sandoval (1.7)
2012: Sandoval (5.5)
Sandoval had an off 2010. He's a very good player.
Shortstop
2010: Uribe (2.5), Renteria (1.2)
2012: Crawford, Fontenot (1.0)
I don't think Crawford can hit enough to be a everyday major leaguer. Giants will probably look outside the organization.
Leftfield
2010: Huff (1.1), Burrell (2.8), Ross (.2), Torres (1.0)
2012: Ross, Belt, Huff (2.0 total)
Same problems as at first. Belt needs to be in the lineup, but where does he play? I have no faith that Huff can bounce back-especially not to his 2010 level
Centerfield
2010: Torres (3.9)
2012: Torres (3.0)
Not a big believer in Torres to put up another year like 2010.
Right field
2010: Schierholtz (.8), Guillen (.2), Huff (1.1)
2012: Huff, Belt, Schierholtz (2 WAR total)?
Who's going to play there? A mish-mash of players. None of them THAT good.
Starting Pitching
2010: Lincecum (5.1), Cain (4.0), Sanchez (2.7), Zito (2.2), Bumgarner (2.2) Wellemeyer (-.7)
2012: Lincecum (5.0), Cain (4.5), Bumgarner (5.0), Sanchez (2.0), Zito/Vogelsong (2.0)
The pitching staff will continue to be very strong. Maybe even better than 2010. The team needs to re-sign Tincecum (he's in his last year of arbitration). Sanchez is a free agent after 2011. Don't know if he'll be back, and don't know how he'll perform after his injury. SF might go with a younger and cheaper option here. Zito and Vogelsong are unknowns. Vogelsong will be eligible for arbitration and will get a huge raise. Maybe Vogelsong and Zito round both round out the rotation with Sanchez moving on?
Relief pitching:
2010: Wilson (2.7), Romo (1.2), Casilla (.9)
2012: Hard to project relievers as bullpens are so fluid. All the important guys from this year come back. How will Wilson respond to his injury?
Adding everything up
2010: Total WAR 47.2
2012: Total WAR 45.5
Call it a toss up.
This year they're on track for about 40 WAR. Give them about 5 more wins next year puts them on track for 90 wins.