Northeast: Baltimore
Midwest: Detroit
South: New Orleans
West: Oakland
I've taken one city from each region of the USA. You'll notice that all of these cities have a pretty battered reputation. But I wanted to make a thread to talk about what each of them have to offer on the positive end. I have been to all of them besides Baltimore. I have been to Washington DC, but never out to Baltimore.
So I'm a bit curious to see what it's got going on.
By the way, all of these cities (besides Oakland) have been a top 10 US city before by population. Let me get those numbers out there. And how they ranked in the top 10 cities census list.
Baltimore:
Highest Point: # 2 (1830, 1840, 1850 censuses Baltimore was the 2nd largest city)
Highest Population: 949,708 (1950 census was it's population peak)
Last Appearance in the top 10:
1980
Current Rank: # 21 (latest estimates released)
New Orleans:
Highest Point: # 3 (in 1840 census it was the 3rd largest city)
Highest Population: 627,525 (1960 census was it's population peak)
Last Appearance in the top 10:
1880
Current Rank: # 53 (latest estimates released)
Detroit:
Highest Point: # 4 (in 1920, 1930, 1940 censuses it was the 4th largest city)
Highest Population: 1,849,568 (1950 census was it's population peak)
Last Appearance in the top 10:
2000
Current Rank: # 11 (latest estimates released)
Oakland:
Highest Point: Never was in top 10
Highest Population: 404,155 (2008 census estimates)
Last Appearance in the top 10: Was never in it
Current Rank: # 44 (latest estimates released)
Notice how all of them are port cities, some of the main ports for their respective regions. Yes Detroit is also a port city, in case you didn't know. Lol.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now I want to do a comparison without people throwing Washington DC & San Francisco/San Jose in this. You can talk about how the location to those cities is beneficial, but I don't want to see people throwing out statistics and numbers for GDP for CSA's and whatnot... let's stick primarily to city on city comparison with some of the immediate suburbs.
Just talk about the actual city and the immediate suburbs (for Baltimore & Oakland)
Here's my question and the theme to answer for these cities:
what are some unique things about any of these cities or even one of these cities (if you don't know about the others)/what do they have to offer today?
How do you feel about these cities?
Do you feel these cities get an overplayed bad reputation or do you think it's deserved?
You can use any criteria to answer the question, like education (universities/colleges), food, architecture, Fortune 500 companies, history, Music scene, art scene, museums, whatever comes to mind etc.... be creative with the criteria- I'm allowing you to come up with criteria on your own for once instead of giving some out.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
My response to my own questions:
I've been to three of those cities (Detroit, Oakland, & New Orleans) and really people over hype the negative qualities for all those cities. I found there to be a lot of nice things about them all.
I have not ever been to Baltimore, but I have heard the Inner Harbor is worth seeing, and that it's one of the best cities in terms of architecture. Then again so is Detroit.
As for skyline, I think Detroit has the best one from what I've seen. Oakland, Baltimore, & New Orleans have a similar sized skyline and all of them have water access nearby.
Detroit:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...oitSkyline.jpg
Baltimore:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...ner_harbor.jpg
Oakland:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/clc-creations/2877459759/ (broken link)
New Orleans:
http://www.locustfork.net/blog/neworleans_skyline1.jpg (broken link)
EDIT-
Side commentary:
I find it a bit strange after looking at this post that one of the cities at their peak was the
2nd largest city in America, another at it's peak was
3rd largest city in America, and another was
4th largest city in America... that's a bit strange for a random sequence, I just picked these cities randomly. All of them besides Oakland seem to have that sequence in this regard. 2,3,4- nice sequence from three different cities from completely different US regions... makes me wish that Oakland had been 5th at some point just to keep the sequence going for this comparison.