Please register to participate in our discussions with 2 million other members - it's free and quick! Some forums can only be seen by registered members. After you create your account, you'll be able to customize options and access all our 15,000 new posts/day with fewer ads.
Part of it is the fact that Chicagoland, minus whatever is in Indiana and Wisconsin, still has a larger population than Philadelphia and Pittsburgh combined and larger metros tend to have higher GDP per capitas so adding Pittsburgh to Philadelphia shouldn't have the exact same effect to the combined GDP as simply increasing Philadelphia's GDP by 38%.
Is that really true? Chicagoland is 8-ish million in Illinois and Philly + Pittsburgh is 8-ism million in Pennsylvania, isn't it? At the very least they are certainly comparable in population.
Last edited by Maintainschaos; 11-14-2019 at 03:03 PM..
Is that really true? Chicagoland is 8-ish million in Illinois and Philly + Pittsburg is 8-ism million in Pennsylvania, isn't it? At the very least they are certainly comparable in population.
A county breakdown in Illinois vs. PA would be helpful for comparing the respective metro areas.
Not rural PA or rural Ill, just the counties in each respective metro. (excluding Indiana, Wisconsin, New Jersey, and Delaware).
Wow. Thank you for doing this. Greatly appreciated. I thought Chicago's MSA within IL was only about ~1,000,000 higher than the combined populations of the Philadelphia MSA and Pittsburgh MSA within PA's boundaries. Chicago truly is a beast!
Wow. Thank you for doing this. Greatly appreciated. I thought Chicago's MSA within IL was only about ~1,000,000 higher than the combined populations of the Philadelphia MSA and Pittsburgh MSA within PA's boundaries. Chicago truly is a beast!
You're welcome, and actually I messed up by relying on Wikipedia for information on delineating the Chicago MSA. When double checking with the most recent delineations from the Census Bureau for 2018 it's an even bigger number for the Chicago MSA population within Illinois: 8,628,040
A county breakdown in Illinois vs. PA would be helpful for comparing the respective metro areas.
Not rural PA or rural Ill, just the counties in each respective metro. (excluding Indiana, Wisconsin, New Jersey, and Delaware).
I totally forgot about the fact that PA's suburbs that contribute to its GDP are heavily populated in NJ and DE. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'd assume the portion of Philly's MSA in other states is much higher than the portion of Chicago's MSA in other states. I mean, South Jersey is pretty heavily populated and is literally right across the river. Chicago's counties in WI and IN are pretty far away and would likely be much smaller and less influential than Camden, Gloucester, Burlington, and New Castle Counties, right?
Mississippi is Tragic by almost every measure and rating.
Mississippi is in the 30s place of GDP. That's not tragic but certainly modest. Per capita income is the lowest in the country but that doesn't equates to poorest as well. Now of the per capita was half or less of the national income sure I'll say it's a well deserve title.
I totally forgot about the fact that PA's suburbs that contribute to its GDP are heavily populated in NJ and DE. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'd assume the portion of Philly's MSA in other states is much higher than the portion of Chicago's MSA in other states. I mean, South Jersey is pretty heavily populated and is literally right across the river. Chicago's counties in WI and IN are pretty far away and would likely be much smaller and less influential than Camden, Gloucester, Burlington, and New Castle Counties, right?
The PA suburban counties are by far the economic leaders of the state and Philadelphia region (Montgomery, Chester, Delaware, Bucks Counties), BUT South Jersey is also home to 2ish million people and very much economically and culturally connected to Philadelphia, much more-so than any neighboring state near Chicago.
Northern Delaware is also home to well over 500,000 people and a huge economic / banking hub for the Philadelphia region.
It does make it harder to compare the two regions because of that.
Please register to post and access all features of our very popular forum. It is free and quick. Over $68,000 in prizes has already been given out to active posters on our forum. Additional giveaways are planned.
Detailed information about all U.S. cities, counties, and zip codes on our site: City-data.com.