Yes, this is an old thread. But I am the king of thread resurrections on CD. So here we go!
CINCINNATI:
Likes: Beautiful skyline/architecture; the Riverfront, wonderful park system; Newport on the Levee; Skyline Chili
Dislikes: The rude and unfriendly locals; traffic; poor, inadequate public transportation
PITTSBURGH: Likes: WONDERFUL skyline, lots and lots and LOTS of beautiful, historic areas; beautiful parks; the inclines and the "T"
Dislikes: Steelers; traffic; poor economy (Pittsburgh is losing population hand-over-fist, really a shame for such a wonderful city)
I don't know a lot about Indianapolis or St. Louis, so I can't make fair judgments of those cities, but one thing I DEFINITELY like about St. Louis is the historical vibe I get by seeing pictures of the city. St. Louis and Pittsburgh draw a lot of comparison in my book, except STL appears to be less hilly.