Score 1 For the 4th Amendment.

[TheWiseWino]

Rodriguez v. United States: A huge win against police overreach at the Supreme Court.

[Unsettomati]

Originally Posted by TheWiseWino

Rodriguez v. United States: A huge win against police overreach at the Supreme Court.

Roberts and Scalia join with the four liberals to come down on the side of the Bill of Rights and against the police state?

Even a couple of stopped clocks are right every once and awhile...

[Juram]

Originally Posted by Unsettomati

Roberts and Scalia join with the four liberals to come down on the side of the Bill of Rights and against the police state?

Even a couple of stopped clocks are right every once and awhile...

Scalia might be the most pro-privacy justice on the entire Supreme Court. Even the article states as much.

Justice Antonin Scalia’s majority vote here is slightly less predictable, but still unsurprising: Scalia is obsessed with privacy protections for property, and has consistently opposed unjustified searches and seizures of automobiles.

He was one of the dissenters in Kelo vs New London which Ginsburg and Souter fully came down on the side of government seizure of property.

[TheWiseWino]

Originally Posted by Unsettomati

Roberts and Scalia join with the four liberals to come down on the side of the Bill of Rights and against the police state?

Even a couple of stopped clocks are right every once and awhile...

Well giving credit where credit is due, Scalia is pretty reliable when it comes to 4th Amendment issues, Roberts on the other hand.... not so much.

https://nelsnewday.wordpress.com/201...-scotus-rules/

[Fifty Seven]

We are 5 posts in to this thread and I still can't tell what it is about.