Which Tiffany necklace would be a better Christmas gift? (fashion, look, difference)

[deepwater88]

Gift would be for my sister who's in her early 20's and very fashion conscious.
I really like both, just cant decide on which is more tasteful!

Tiffany 1837

Tiffany 1837

[RedZin]

Originally Posted by deepwater88

Gift would be for my sister who's in her early 20's and very fashion conscious.
I really like both, just cant decide on which is more tasteful!

Tiffany 1837

Tiffany 1837

I tend not to go for Tiffany stuff that has the name engraved on the front of it, but of the two, I prefer the horseshoe.

My favorite silver Tiffany pendants are the Tiffany key pendants and the Elsa Peretti Heart pendants.

[Pitt Chick]

I prefer the interlocking circles.

If your sister is really into horses, the horseshoe one would be okay.

[SXMGirl]

Originally Posted by Pitt Chick

I prefer the interlocking circles.

If your sister is really into horses, the horseshoe one would be okay.

This. I think the horseshoe is not nearly as popular, thus the difference in price Also, with the interlocking circles, your sister can add other charms (or what we Philly people call medals), while you cannot easily do that with the horseshoe.

[Amisi]

Definnitely the interlocking circles ---- unless, as a previous poster said, she is into horses. Even still, I like the circles better.

I'm getting my daughter a Tiffany necklace for her Sweet 16 next year and it's a toss up between this interlocking circles or the key pendant.

[skelaki]

The interlocking circles

[hellpaso]

I like the one with circles. The horseshoe is nice, but it reminds me of the horseshoe necklace fad after it was on Sex & the City about 12-15 years ago.

[8635angelvalley]

Originally Posted by deepwater88

Gift would be for my sister who's in her early 20's and very fashion conscious.
I really like both, just cant decide on which is more tasteful!

Tiffany 1837

Tiffany 1837

If your sister is not a horsewoman I would go for the circles. Horseshoe is kind of gamblerish/Vegas/lucky


Vintage Peretti Bean-the big one

[Ted Bear]

Please do not 'splurge' on a Tiffany piece.

If you find something which you like, take the design/designs/ideas to a private jeweler (not a storefront operation) and have them make a nice piece for you.

The work will be of much higher quality, and much lower price. Probably half of the price of the Tiffany pieces which you showed goes for the cache of the little blue box. We've all been there, but learned our lesson. You can learn it early in life and give your sister a piece of heirloom quality which she will treasure for a lifetime.

[TabulaRasa]

The horseshoe is less classic and more likely to look dated. The interlocking circles will be able to be worn for longer, because it's not really part of a trend. I have an Elsa Peretti heart, but I don't wear it much, because the chain is shorter than I'd like, and I didn't really want to buy a new Tiffany chain for a present someone else got me.