If a girl is drunk, is it okay to have sex with her? (2013, own)

[Pinkmani]

In August of last year, Dr. Phil tweeted this:

http://static01.mediaite.com/med/wp-....32.14-PM1.png

Consent
“intelligent, knowing, and voluntary consent and does not include coerced submission”

“shall not be deemed or construed to mean the failure of the alleged victim to offer physical resistance to the offender”

Incapacity
“mentally defective”: “mental disease or defect which renders a person temporarily or permanently incapable of appraising the nature of his or her conduct”

“mentally incapacitated”: “temporarily incapable of appraising or controlling a person’s own conduct due to the influence of a narcotic, anesthetic, or intoxicating substance administered without his or her consent or due to nay other act committed upon that person without his or her consent”

“physically helpless”: “unconscious, asleep, or for any other reason physically unable to communicate unwillingness to act”

“physically incapacitated”: “bodily impaired or handicapped and substantially limited in ability to resist or flee”

My answer to Dr. Phil's tweet yes and no because it depends on the circumstances. So, I'd like to know whether or not you would consider the following scenarios to be rape:

1. Two sober people who both consent to sex
2. Two sober people where one doesn't consent to sex
3. A drunk person initiates sex with a sober person
4. A sober person initiates sex with a drunk person
5. Two drunk people have sex
6. A drunk person initiates sex with a passed-out drunk
7. A sober person initiates sex with a passed-out drunk

[stan4]

You would be a freaking stupid ass for sleeping with a drunk person.
For several reasons.

[blktoptrvl]

Police now advertise that buzzed driving IS drunk driving.

So, I put this inevitable question along with the OP's question. Is buzzed sex the same as drunk sex and how do you identify/draw the line?

[Pinkmani]

Originally Posted by blktoptrvl

Police now advertise that buzzed driving IS drunk driving.

So, I put this inevitable question along with the OP's question. Is buzzed sex the same as drunk sex and how do you identify/draw the line?

Good point! I guess the answer is to bring back prohibition! One could also argue, "How do you know if they were drunk?"

[Frostnip]

A girl? Not okay. A woman? Depends on the circumstances.

[espn_lies]

Originally Posted by stan4

You would be a freaking stupid ass for sleeping with a drunk person.
For several reasons.

Is this a serious reply?

[CSD610]

Is it really a serious question?

I just don't know where to begin so I think I will just refrain from a possible time out and go to bed.

[mbradleyc]

Shoot! That's the only way I can get any.

[blueherons]

I don't know about having sex with a drunk, passed out person but it definitely isn't okay to have sex with a corpse.

Dead people smell.

[rainroosty]

"Dr." Phil?