1858 Remington Army or 1860 Colt Army?

[Chango]

I like the Colt purely for looks. I love the look of old open top revolvers.

[MarqueseGilmore]

Originally Posted by kstalcup59

Clint used a 1851 Navy in "The Outlaw Josie Wales". He used a 1858 New Army In "Pale Rider".

In "The Outlaw of Josie Wales" Clint used.......
Two 1847 colt walkers......I do believe he had a pocket navy and 1860 Army........I'll google it to be sure!

[Stac2007]

Originally Posted by JMadison

Which do you fell is the better cap and ball revolver, why?

(Talking modern replicas here, not true vintage examples. Though if you want to talk about those, do identify the fact. I'm interested in shooters not collectibles in this thread, though of course design features overlap.)

I always like the full frame Remington 1858 but thats me.