Amnesty for illegal aliens (naturalization, medical, health care, visas)

[DSNYSANMAN]

Originally Posted by makossa

This thread needs to be moved!!!

Why do you care where this thread is?

[cochi loco]

Why does this thread need to be moved? This issue affects us NYers as much as it affects Arizonans whether people want to hear it or not. Unless you dont pay taxes......

Of course, we arent experiencing the violence AZ is, we don't border Mexico. That's part of the reason Mexicans are on the spotlight right now, compared to other ethnic groups. Unfair? Sure. But the violence is realm and everyone wants to condemn Gov. Jan Brewer. Question is....what do we do????

[goldengrain]

Originally Posted by cochi loco

Rubies, I agree with you that these people need to be identified and they need to pay taxes. Realistically, how does the government deport 12 million people? However, our President simply wants to appease one of his largest voting blocks. He is only interested in being re-elected. He could care less about breaking the backs of taxpayers. I think a fair, realistic approach would be some sort of identification program where illegals are allowed to work and pay taxes while they qualify for citizenship. Most importantly, our borders need to be shut and the bleeding stopped, as someone else stated.

That was exactly the argument that the government used to get us to give them amnisty the last time. The government promised it would NEVER happen again. Obviously, that did not work. This is why people are so angry now.

We have been told many illegals went back to Mexico because our economy went downhill. We don't have to deport them, just make sure nobody hires them and they'll manage to get home the way they managed to come here in the first place.

I am sorry if people have abused them, but look at all the Latino drug gangs in this country and the damage they have done. Look at their population in our prisons.

No, we cannot give them special papers to work here because Americans are out of work. The lower down the economic ladder you go the higher the unemployment figures are. They are putting Americans out of work by keeping wages for those low level jobs too low. The best plan is to let Americans take those jobs and then THEY will pay the taxes.

They are nothing but a drain on the economy. We can no longer afford them.

Just make sure nobody hires or gives them lodging without really stiff penalties and make sure there are trained inspectors to check on these things. It will be easy to get rid of them. Then, our unemployment figures will change.

[makossa]

Originally Posted by goldengrain

That was exactly the argument that the government used to get us to give them amnisty the last time. The government promised it would NEVER happen again. Obviously, that did not work. This is why people are so angry now.

We have been told many illegals went back to Mexico because our economy went downhill. We don't have to deport them, just make sure nobody hires them and they'll manage to get home the way they managed to come here in the first place.

I am sorry if people have abused them, but look at all the Latino drug gangs in this country and the damage they have done. Look at their population in our prisons.

No, we cannot give them special papers to work here because Americans are out of work. The lower down the economic ladder you go the higher the unemployment figures are. They are putting Americans out of work by keeping wages for those low level jobs too low. The best plan is to let Americans take those jobs and then THEY will pay the taxes.

They are nothing but a drain on the economy. We can no longer afford them.

Just make sure nobody hires or gives them lodging without really stiff penalties and make sure there are trained inspectors to check on these things. It will be easy to get rid of them. Then, our unemployment figures will change.

If our spineless incompetent government would grow the ba**s to enforce the immigration laws already on the books we wouldn’t be in this mess. I think many illegal’s may even self deport if our foolish leaders in Washington would do their job. I read today that many are packing up and leaving AZ already.

[DSNYSANMAN]

At first I was very pro AZ's new law but after reading about it I am against it. Because of this law many illegals are leaving AZ in record numbers for other states. I dont want anymore illegals here better they stay in AZ then come to NY. We already have an illegal problem now it will get worse.

[makossa]

Originally Posted by DSNYSANMAN

At first I was very pro AZ's new law but after reading about it I am against it. Because of this law many illegals are leaving AZ in record numbers for other states. I dont want anymore illegals here better they stay in AZ then come to NY. We already have an illegal problem now it will get worse.

Maybe because of the migration out of AZ other states (??? incl. NY, someday ???) will have to follow suit and implement those same laws as Arizona. It could come down to where state-by-state we'll do the job of enforcing the illegal immigration laws that the Feds refused to do.

[goldengrain]

Originally Posted by DSNYSANMAN

At first I was very pro AZ's new law but after reading about it I am against it. Because of this law many illegals are leaving AZ in record numbers for other states. I dont want anymore illegals here better they stay in AZ then come to NY. We already have an illegal problem now it will get worse.

Boy, that's a really poorly thought out statement.

It sounds like somebody who favored these lawbreakers would say to try to get us to doubt ourselves, but we all know you wouldn't be doing that, don't we?

Other states are following suit (at least 6) with their own versions of the Arizona law.
If Arizona moves them to other states the other states will protest and before you know it, everyone will be speaking English and paying taxes and our own poor(a growing group) will be getting jobs at a decent wage again.
The poorer you are, the higher your unemployment, so Obama's 'new jobs' will be opening up. It is great news and we should support Arizona in any way we can.

[makossa]

Originally Posted by goldengrain

Boy, that's a really poorly thought out statement.

It sounds like somebody who favored these lawbreakers would say to try to get us to doubt ourselves, but we all know you wouldn't be doing that, don't we?

Other states are following suit (at least 6) with their own versions of the Arizona law.
If Arizona moves them to other states the other states will protest and before you know it, everyone will be speaking English and paying taxes and our own poor(a growing group) will be getting jobs at a decent wage again.
The poorer you are, the higher your unemployment, so Obama's 'new jobs' will be opening up. It is great news and we should support Arizona in any way we can.

I love that!!! (In Bold) Isn't it sad that it takes millions of us angry taxpayers to get pushed in to a corner and still, those fools in DC still don't get it. Obama filing a lawsuit against AZ Don't jump all over me people, I actually voted for this non-starter socialist - Won't make that mistake twice!!!

[knowledgeiskey]

Originally Posted by RUBIES77

After reading the pros and cons here about illegal aliens, this is what I think:

Our present and prior government has done very little to solve the problem. About 10 to 15 years' ago, when the Illegals began coming here en mass, our government began building a wall on the California side. The wall has been built, the border patrol has become more corrupt, and the problem is still unsolved...............the government has become more wishy-washy, and nothing gets resolved. A lot of these Illegals have children now born in the USA, and are still not paying taxes.

Remember, that we have here Illegal aliens from many parts of the world besides Mexico! They are getting paid under the table, and we are not getting a share of the taxes, so the government should give them amnesty, allow them to identify themselves, work toward citizenship, and pay taxes........problem solved.

Now, we should concentrate our efforts in keeping our borders away from people that want to cross here illegally, and do a better job.............

Illegals pay taxes. If they buy food to eat, they are contributing to the system being that they paid a sales tax.

I think that there is nothing you can do from keeping people from going to a land mass that they wish to be.

Remember. Borders are imaginary.

[makossa]

Originally Posted by knowledgeiskey

Illegals pay taxes. If they buy food to eat, they are contributing to the system being that they paid a sales tax.

Are you suggesting that because illegals pay taxes on their food and other purchases that that equates to what we pay in state, federal, and city income tax??? We also pay taxes on all our purchases as well as the ones I mentioned. Sorry, that don't fly!!!! They're paying pennies compared to the rest of us!!!