Dog sentenced to die for protection owner from illegal alien (medical, married)

[GH0ST..]

Originally Posted by Bummer

Why not, GHOST?

Their mere presence in this country ILLEGALLY justifies PUNISHMENT.

ok. but when one commits a violent crime, why is that used as a justification for deporting them all? if you want to call them all illegal border crossers, fine. but isnt it a bit inaccurate to generalize them all as violent criminals?

[andreabeth]

Originally Posted by southernbliss

Are charges being brought on the illegal for animal cruelty? he hit the dog with a rake, the dog at this time had not bite him so it seems there would be charges would be on the illegal also.

I'd say to this illegal- right back at ya!

1. the illegal hit the dogs with a metal rake- I'd call PETA, the ASPCA anybody against cruelty to animals and try to get them involved. If he hit the dogs with a metal rake, there should be charges that can be filed against him. He also trespassed on private property after clearly being told not to.

2. he grabbed the wife and dragged her to the ground, causing her to scream- can you say 'assault and battery'? If that had been my home and this exemplary individual had laid so much as one finger on me or any of my family, he would have been led away in handcuffs. If it was me he unwisely chose to wrestle to the ground, I would sue for emotional distress because I would have nightmares for the rest of my life.

3. I'd go after this 'landscaping company'. They are obviously hiring illegals and need to be punished. I would want an explanation as to why they thought it would be OK to send illegal workers to my property.

I am off to sign the petition. And see if I can send these folks some money to help with their legal bills.

[Miborn]

Originally Posted by Vagabond

So kids, the moral of this story is sneak across the boarder, go into a well to-do suburb, find a yard with a dog and jump the fence, antagonize the dog into biting, and BINGO! you've hit the lottery!

This country is ripe for the taking - China, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, etc., come on down the Price Is Right!

Thats about right too. My dogs would do the same thing! That is their job.
They probable didn't know English to go back to their truck and wait! Their fault if so.
Also, to attack the dogs with a rake they knew what the dogs would do. sounds like a set up to me.

[The Dissenter]

Originally Posted by GH0ST..

ok. but when one commits a violent crime, why is that used as a justification for deporting them all? if you want to call them all illegal border crossers, fine. but isnt it a bit inaccurate to generalize them all as violent criminals?

they may not be violent criminals. but they are still criminals for illegally entering the US.

Throw them all out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!

[ProLogic]

Originally Posted by Alanboy395

they may not be violent criminals. but they are still criminals for illegally entering the US.

Throw them all out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!

Again, crossing the border is not a crime. It is a Civil offense. I have said this in the past and will say it again, crossing the border is equivalent to J-walking across a state line.

[JesusisLord]

Originally Posted by GH0ST..

i cant generalize the entire body of them. but id be willing to say that the vast majority are harmless people.

Right on Brotha! Well Said! This is absolutely true, but they are scapegoated as being hardcore criminals.

[Jim280]

Originally Posted by Alanboy395

this is REALLY upsetting. a dog does its job by protecting its owners from scum which happens to be an illegal and he'll get put to sleep. The owner warned the illegal (even in that stupid illegal's language.) That illegal operated at his own risk once he got the warning.

Also if that illegal had grabbed my wife, he would have been getting a payout from my insurance b/c i tore his illegal behind apart piece by piece. if he even lived to recieve the payout.

dont get mad at the dog b/c he followed his instinct by protecting his owner. and that illegal needs to be charged with animal crulety.

I agree, if he put his hands on my wife or hit my dog he would be deported in a body bag.

[Bummer]

Originally Posted by ProLogic

Again, crossing the border is not a crime. It is a Civil offense. I have said this in the past and will say it again, crossing the border is equivalent to J-walking across a state line.

Come on, ProLogic . . . FEEBLE ARGUMENT!

What about Welfare Fraud?
What about ID Theft?
What about using False ID's?
What about Driving without a License?
What about Driving without Insurance?
What about Cheating the Legal Citizens out of Taxes?

and the list goes on and on . . .

[The Dissenter]

Originally Posted by ProLogic

Again, crossing the border is not a crime. It is a Civil offense. I have said this in the past and will say it again, crossing the border is equivalent to J-walking across a state line.

Then explain why they are called "Illegal" immigrants?

[astrogal]

Where does it say those landscapers are illegal? It says nothing in the article, and I have run searches and am not coming up with anything saying the landscapers were illegal? Am I missing something? OP-source please.