Quote:
Originally Posted by Woodrow LI
That is all fine. but will be based upon how one defines Islam. Even among Muslims there is considerable difference in how we define it.
The direct translation of Islam is "Performing the action of submitting to Allah(swt)"
With all the flavors we come in. It may be noticiale we vary widely in how we do that.
Those of us that claim to practice Islam form a very wide bandwidth in the Islam spectrum
.
The wide width of the Islam spectrum runs from those who view all adherents of a Monotheistic religion as performing Islam to Only the adherents of a specific madhab perform Islam.
|
Principle of Substance versus Form
You are emphasizing too much on the Form rather that the Substance. As I mentioned somewhere, there is the principle of
Substance versus Form in reality and human nature.
Analogy 1:
In terms of
Energy necessary to sustain life, there is its Substance and the Forms.
The Substance and ultimate of the Energy business within a human organism is to get the various nutrients to the cells.
The penultimate to this core system is a whole lot of generic sub-systems that is common to ALL human beings, e.g. the digestive system, etc.
As to its forms, there are a wide variety of how food are obtained, grown, prepared and eaten that vary with locations, ethnicity, etc.
Thus when we understand all the mechanics of the Energy-Digestive System we can fit in whatever has to do with food and nutrition into the generic model.
For example, we can easily understand the ultimate purpose of fasting and how it fit into the substance of the human nutrition-energy system and optimal health. Those who do not understand will be gluttons after each fasting and end up heavier [more obese] than before they started fasting.
Analogy 2:
It is the same for the Substance and Form regarding
sex, of which the ultimate [the substance] is to get the sperm to meet up with ovum.
There are many other generic sub-systems that support the main [substance] of the consummation of sex.
However as for the Forms there is a great diversity of activities but their ultimate is to lead to the substance of getting the sperm to consolidate with the ovum.
Personal grooming may seem independent but actually that is a form of activity that is leading to the consummation of sex.
There could be hundreds and thousand of human activities in various forms which are ultimately directed to its ultimate purpose.
There are many other human systems that has its substance [ultimate purpose] with a wide variety of forms.
Th
e Spiritual-Religio System in Humans
One of the main human system is the Spiritual-Religio system which has generic 'substance' within all human beings.
The different types of spirituality and religions are merely various forms with its own variety of forms.
Islam is thus merely one of the forms that support the spiritual-religion system of humans. Within Islam there are sub-forms, i.e. different sects, etc. The problem with many Muslims is they are brainwashed to think Islam is the superior and perfect religion for mankind.
Reality is Islam is merely a form of the spiritual-religion system of human beings and Islam is
one of the inferior forms as compared to other forms such as those from the Eastern religions and spirituality. This can be easily proven and justified by the terrible evils associated with SOME Muslims being catalyzed directly by SOME evil laden verses in its holy texts.
In contrast, there is no* such evil manifestation
directly from the holy texts in other existing main religions. * If any, rare & not critical, or misinterpreted.
Islam is also very much weaker in other spiritual criteria, e.g. development of Spiritual Quotient in real neural terms, Morality Quotient, Wisdom Quotient.
If one understand Islam as "
Performing the action of submitting to Allah(swt)", which is a form and without fitting it within the generic human Spiritual-Religio system [substance], then one is like to be lost in their spiritual journey.
It is the failure* of SOME [or most] Muslims in understanding where Islam stand in relation to the generic spiritual-religio system within humans that trigger them [SOME] to commit terrible evils in the name of the religion, the prophet and God. * Why? - there is a good reason for it.