There were so many responses to
this thread, that I thought I'd compile a list of local eateries based on everyone's recommendations. To me there's nothing better than supporting local fare, and I'm looking forward to getting started!
Casual Dining/Soups/Sandwiches:
A.P. Roots & A.P. Suggins
Alfalfa's
Buddy's Bar & Grill
Courtyard Deli (open M-F from 11-2 only!)
Cheapside Bar & Grill
Giacomos (NY style deli)
Harry's (see Malone's/Sal's/Harry's combo below)
Ramsey's (diner style)
Sawyer's Bar & Grill (good burgers/casual flare)
Stanley J's (NY style deli)
Sunrise Bakery (also for pastries/desserts)
Tolly Ho
Two Keys Tavern ("pub grub")
Pizza/Grinders/Subs:
Brooklyn Pizza
Mancino's Pizza & Grinders
Pazzo's Pizza Pub
Smashing Tomato
Steaks/Seafood/Italian:
Bellini's
Harry's/Malone's/Sal's combo: (Malone's and Sal's for steaks, seafood, etc., Harry's for sandwiches)
Merrick Inn/Murray's
Rossi's
Pastries/Desserts:
Le Matin
Magee's Bakery
Spalding's Bakery (voted best donuts!)
(they do not have a website, but try
this for an interesting read)
Other:
7 Leguas (Mexican)
Atomic Café (Caribbean/Jamaican flair)
Billy's BBQ (self-explanatory, but it's BBQ)
Bourbon & Toulouse (http://www.bntlex.com/dtown.htm - broken link) (Cajun)
China Hut (Chinese)
Jalapenos Mexican Restaurant (Mexican)
Mandarin (Asian)
Miyako Sushi & Steakhouse (Japanese/sushi)
Oasis (Mediterranean)
Planet Thai (Thai)
Siam Thai (Thai)
Tomo Restaurant (Japanese/sushi)
And finally, some
recommended chains:
Chipotle (Mexican)
Donato's Pizza, Subs, Salads
Graeter's Ice Cream (I'm recommending this one, they have fantastic ice cream at a reasonable price! Try the raspberry chunk…)
Jimmy Johns (subs)
Pita Pit (pitas)
Puccini's Smiling Teeth (pizza)
Hope this helps any newcomers to the area, and if I labeled anything incorrectly, just give a shout!