Lake Fishing in Suffolk County? (Brookhaven, Islip: live in, pine, best)

[DeadPool1998]

Does anyone know of any little lakes I can shore fish with my 4 year old on Long Island? I live in northern Suffolk.

Thanks.

[DawnSells]

What about Caleb Smith on Jericho in Smiththown? I believe they stock the lake.

[KellyFG]

The best Lake fishing on Long Island is Lake Panamoka but its for use by members only.
however there are ponds that are connected to the lake that are full of fish, the only problem is they have alot of lilly pads.
Lake Panamoka is in Ridge, between RT 25 & Rt 25A
Corey Pond is also full of fish, its on Town of Brookhaven property, located slightly southest of Lake Panamoka.

[DeadPool1998]

Originally Posted by DawnSells

What about Caleb Smith on Jericho in Smiththown? I believe they stock the lake.

Caleb Smith was cute and unimposing for a 4 year old, but it was too shallow and overgrown to fish. I'd like to find another place.

[MissMets]

Artist Lake, Middle Island - NYS Dept. of Environmental Conservation

[Johninwestbury]

How about Pine Lake in Middle Island? I was there a couple of Saturdays ago and it was loaded with Rainbow Trout.

[Johninwestbury]

Also there's the Peconic Lakes area off Forge Rd and S.River. Also Sears or Bellows Pond in Sears-Bellows County Park.

[savehtekiwi]

does anyone know of any of the peasy pond, wood choppers pond, duck pond, sandy pond, and grassy pond are there any big pickerel in those lakes

[lubby]

Can you fish at belmont lake state park? They have a lake there. Also brookwood Hall in Islip has a big lake too.

[lubby]

This is the lake I was talking about at Brookwood Hall I took many pictures when I was there. This is one of them. Not sure if you can fish there but you could call brookwood hall and ask.