For what it is worth, Elmira, Corning, Binghamton, Utica and Watertown make the top 10 on the Small Town Charm: America's Best Hometowns Ranked list:
https://www.allstarhome.com/resource...america-ranked
Here is the methodology...
To come up with the ranking, we analyzed the cities named in the 50 smallest TV designated market areas with a population of less than 100,000. To determine our ranking, we compared cities across four key metrics and graded each metric on a 100-point scale. The four metrics were:
Community – 50 points overall
Diversity by state – 20 points
Historic buildings by city – 10 points
Farmer’s markets within 30 miles – 10 points
High school football winning percentage – 10 points
Safety – 20 points
Affordable living – 15 points
Education – 15 points
Sources include the FBI Crime Data Explorer, Zillow Home Values, National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau, National Park Service, and the United States Department of Agriculture. The average high school football winning percentage is based on 2022-2023 season or the most recent season data available.