Can you distinguish between a Hindu and a Muslim? (generation, radical, extremist)

[Sikaranista]

Originally Posted by sailordave

The problem comes in recognizing which religion the person is so as not to offend them. If I know someone is Hindu, I wouldn't offer them a hamburger or a beef steak. If I know someone is Muslim or Jewish I wouldn't offer them shellfish or pork.

This is why many Indian dishes are vegetarian. They can be enjoyed by all.

Remember, even Americans that aren't among those ethnic groups still have dietary rules. Some folks are vegetarians by their own choosing. Some folks are allergic to shellfish. Other folks have been told by their docs to not eat red meat. Approach it the same way.

"You'll have to tell me what you like to eat? Do you like XXXX or would you prefer something else?"

[PamelaD]

I can tell the nationality of an Inidian and the nationality of an Arab, but I have never been able to look at someone and know their religion. Muslim covers many nationalities.

[LexusNexus]

Originally Posted by zox

I'm East Indian and Hindu. I'm clean shaven and don't speak with an accent. Indians like myself can easily distinguish us from Muslims including Pakastani or Persians (Iranians). However, do you know the difference between a Hindu and a Muslim or do you think we have the same religion and views because we resemble each other. The reason I ask is Hindus particularly in India are some of the most anti-Muslim people you will ever meet. In fact, they were anti-Muslim before it became fashionable to be anti-Muslim. I don't advocate those particular views and feel like it's a form of discrimination but I was just curious if people on this forum know the difference between Hindus and Muslims or are we the same to you. It's okay if you answer yes. I would like to hear your views. Just be honest

No, I can't distingush. How about an explanation?

[momonkey]

Originally Posted by zox

I'm East Indian and Hindu. I'm clean shaven and don't speak with an accent. Indians like myself can easily distinguish us from Muslims including Pakastani or Persians (Iranians). However, do you know the difference between a Hindu and a Muslim or do you think we have the same religion and views because we resemble each other. The reason I ask is Hindus particularly in India are some of the most anti-Muslim people you will ever meet. In fact, they were anti-Muslim before it became fashionable to be anti-Muslim. I don't advocate those particular views and feel like it's a form of discrimination but I was just curious if people on this forum know the difference between Hindus and Muslims or are we the same to you. It's okay if you answer yes. I would like to hear your views. Just be honest

I know! I know! People who belong to the Hindu religion don't hate America, Christians or Jews.

[LauraC]

If we are talking geographical origin, it's easier for me to wait until they speak. People from India, who speak English, have distinct accents. Plus, Indian women dress, colorfully. The food is different. Indian food is hot (to me). When I was younger, I had a female roommate (2 years) from India who worked at the Indian embassy in DC. She had been educated in England and spoke more proper English than my other roommate who actually was born and raised in a blue collar part of England. The Indians I came in contact with in the US, back then, were happy friendly fun people. (They still may be, I just don't live in a large city, anymore so I don't come in contact with them.) If we are talking Muslim versus Hindu, Hindus have many gods (and holidays ) and generally don't want to kill us. Muslim cab drivers (at US airports) didn't speak to me when I used to travel for work. Is that because I was an American or because I was a woman traveling alone...I don't know...but they left an unfriendly impression.

[GregW]

I cannot, at a glance, tell a Muslim from a Hindu from a Buddist but they can.

[Neuling]

Originally Posted by zox

I'm East Indian and Hindu. I'm clean shaven and don't speak with an accent. Indians like myself can easily distinguish us from Muslims including Pakastani or Persians (Iranians). However, do you know the difference between a Hindu and a Muslim or do you think we have the same religion and views because we resemble each other. The reason I ask is Hindus particularly in India are some of the most anti-Muslim people you will ever meet. In fact, they were anti-Muslim before it became fashionable to be anti-Muslim. I don't advocate those particular views and feel like it's a form of discrimination but I was just curious if people on this forum know the difference between Hindus and Muslims or are we the same to you. It's okay if you answer yes. I would like to hear your views. Just be honest

If you are East Indian and grew up there, you do have an accent, although you might not be aware of it

Anyway, I don't quite understand your question. Are you referring to looks only? The two religions are completely different, but if Indians of both religions wear the same clothes, it might be difficult or impossible to tell the difference.

My Indian friend (Hinidu) is also very anti-Islam.

[Jaymie]

We in America shun God in the public school . We learn nothing about the difference or similarities . Its a crime the way public schools teach very little in 12 years .

[aveojohn]

The difference is, Muslims have this block of wood on their shoulder.

[citizenkane2]

You can convert to another religion from Hindu, without fear of death.

That's the biggest difference for me.