I could spend an hour writing reasons that debunk this argument, but if you had simply posted the entire list, that would have done it for me LOL. You actually already did that by saying that the top states are energy states.
The Best and Worst Run States in America: A Survey of All 50 - 24/7 Wall St.
1. North Dakota(R controlled)
2. Wyoming ( R Controlled)
3. Nebraska(non partisian unicarmil legislature)
4. Utah ( R Controlled)
5. Iowa( by the way, Secretary of Ag. Tom Vilsack ran this state til 2009 and the current Legislature make up is Dems hold the senate, Republicans hold the house)
6. Alaska ( R Controlled)
7. South Dakota (R Controlled)
8. Vermont(democrat controlled)
9. Virginia (Republican controlled, but Senate tied 20/20)
10. Minnesota( D gov, R H & S)
11. Delaware (Democrat controlled)
12. Tennessee( Republican controlled)
13. Texas( Republican controlled
14. New Hampshire ( Democrat controlled)
15. Kansas ( Republican controlled, was run by current S of HHS Kathleem Sebelius)
16. Washington( Democrat controlled
17. Oregon (Democrat controlled, but house tied 30/30)
18. Montana( Dem Gov, R H&S)
19. Massachusetts ( Democrat controlled
20. Pennsylvania (Republican controlled, first time in like 10 years)
21. Wisconsin (R controlled)
22. Idaho ( R controlled)
23. Indiana ( R controlled)
24. West Virginia (D Controlled)
25. Missouri ( R Controlled
26. Maryland ( D Controlled)
27. North Carolina ( R Controlled)
28. Alabama (R controlled, in its 2nd recession in 3 years, how is it #28 ????)
29. Colorado (Dem controlled)
30. Ohio ( R Controlled)
31. Michigan (R Controlled)
32. Arkansas (R Controlled)
33. Oklahoma ( R Controlled
34. Georgia ( R Controlled)
35. Maine (R G, D H&S)
36. Connecticut (D controlled)
37. Kentucky ( R Controlled )
38. Hawaii ( D Controlled)
39. New York ( D Gov, R Senate, D House)
40. Mississippi ( R controlled)
41. Louisiana ( R controlled)
42. Florida ( R Controlled)
43. South Carolina ( R Controlled)
44. New Mexico (R gov, D H&S)
45. Nevada (R gov, D H&S)
46. New Jersey ( R gov, D H&S)
47. Arizona ( R Controlled)
48. Illinois ( D Controlled
49. Rhode Island ( D controlled)
50. California ( D Controlled)
the link itself goes into more details, but its obvious those states arent at the top just because they are run by republicans. If it was, then there wouldnt be so much interchanging in the middle, it would be all R's at the top and all Dems at the bottom.