Do you think there should be a muslim registry or database in the U.S.? (poll, suspected)

[Sundaydrive00]

Originally Posted by Clark Park

If we register all Muslims in the US, how about we also register all Jews in the US?

I mean, the vast majority of American Jews are liberal and Democrats ... wouldn't that make sense to those that that are trying to create a Christian conservative republican nation?

Judaism has its roots in the Middle East, can we really trust them?

[elan]

Can we add Catholic Charities to the list, they sponsored yesterday's attacker.

[bentlebee]

Any person who poses a threat to the US should be in a database. No exceptions for race, religion, etc.

[OotsaPootsa]

Originally Posted by bentlebee

Any person who poses a threat to the US should be in a database. No exceptions for race, religion, etc.

Don't you think that any person who poses a threat to the US is already in a database, regardless of race, religion, etc.?

[OotsaPootsa]

Originally Posted by elan

Can we add Catholic Charities to the list, they sponsored yesterday's attacker.

Yes, and just think of the acts of terrorism the IRA perpetrated over the years.

[OotsaPootsa]

Originally Posted by golimar

99% of terrorist organizations spread all across the world belong to one religion.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_o...rrorist_groups

You've made that claim before. Break down the numbers and prove that 99% figure, will you?

[Steve McDonald]

Originally Posted by Snowball7

There already is a Muslim database.

They know most about most Americans.

Yes, the question is not "Should there be a database?", because there already is. Muslims have been singled-out, registered and put under surveillance secretly for a long time. Any pretense that their rights have been respected, is false. What Trump has threatened, is just a more open version of what has been done to them previously. It's a necessary part of a fascist takeover, to brand a minority as an enemy and blame them for the troubles of a society.

Read this thread: //www.city-data.com/forum/polit...riff-town.html

[shihku7]

some context:
the number of Americans killed by Christians since 9/11 is around 200,000.

number of Americans killed by Muslims since 9/11... 3,000-ish?

Muslim Americans seem to have much lower murder rates than native citizens, but they have a higher super villain/terrorist rate. I get that people are afraid of these rare super villains. But this terrorist rate is really extremely low no matter how you look at it. What we're scared of is the fact that mass killing ability is so easy to achieve for any nut job.

[illtaketwoplease]

Yes, the question is not "should there be a database", because there already is. Muslims have been singled-out, registered and surveilled secretly for a long time. Any pretense that their rights have been respected, is false.

Have any proof of this ?

[Statz2k10]

Originally Posted by shihku7

some context:
the number of Americans killed by Christians since 9/11 is around 200,000.

number of Americans killed by Muslims since 9/11... 3,000-ish?

Muslim Americans seem to have much lower murder rates than native citizens, but they have a higher super villain/terrorist rate. I get that people are afraid of these rare super villains. But this terrorist rate is really extremely low no matter how you look at it. What we're scared of is the fact that mass killing ability is so easy to achieve for any nut job.

The 200,000 you mention. Is that from murders, gun violence etc?

I've never been effected but I think that if a loved one of mine was killed in a terrorist attack on US soil I'd be hurting more for the simple fact that my country let me down in protecting my loved on.